Official Everybody Edits Forums

bliske

Member

Joined: 2015-04-05

Posts: 411

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

glad to hear that this will be official rather then the discussion regarding the top 12 finalists that actually deserve the position, i don't care if we don't get the spot, i just mean, some place's that got #1 compared to other's that got #3rd, need to be opposite, etc.

Baticon

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

Peh.My world isnt even in the first 25

mustang

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

UPDATE - We have all the numbers crunched from the four categories (gameplay, art, concept, and integration). All we need to do now is to have as many judges as possible sit down and review the final ranking before we release the list. I know we said we would do that today, but unfortunately by the time we finished the scoring many judges had already left due to time zone differences.

We know that with prizes on the line it's best for us to sit down and have one last quality check to make sure the order is accepted by as many of our available judges as possible, so please understand this last delay is to ensure the best maps do in fact win.

I'll make sure to release the winners in about 17-18 hours from now, hopefully not too much longer than that. This is the final delay since the numbers are done and we just want to get approval before the results are published. Thanks for your patience.

Cyral

Member

From: United States

Joined: 2015-02-15

Posts: 2,269

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

^Yay i guess

---

Player Since 2011. I used to make bots and stuff.

BEE

Member

Joined: 2015-03-14

Posts: 1,679

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

What you don't know is that the judges are actually convening to secretly take over the world.

---

Custom Tab: Forum Post|Trello

Thanks Xen for my Avatar and Smitty for the smiley

mustang

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

UPDATE - Just a heads up, the results will be released soon.

How this will work is we will post the results in this thread, and we will start a new thread for the feedback. The top 25 will receive some very detailed feedback, so hopefully this will help for future competitions.

We also plan on featuring highlights of several maps in addition to the top 12 and the feedback we already mentioned, so expect many updates throughout the day.

Make sure to check back soon to see the results!

Last edited by mustang (Dec 2 2011 12:39:20 pm)

EENinja

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

I will be watiing

Im really looking foward to seeing what you think.

MRBOOGAWESOME

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

Nice to hear. Cant wait !

mustang

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

UPDATE - At long last, the results are in!

---------------------- Tier 1 Prizes ----------------------

1st Place - #99 cod-stormers
Members: JAA, haka, musuki, lecture, koth
"hakashouseoffun"
www.everybodyedits.com/games/PWjwXetUUSbEI

2nd Place - #33. The Mighty Morphin Block Arrangers
Members: DKLevels, EEDD,Fir3fli3, Deadlord, Zoidy
"Skull Citadel"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWeTI0z4m3a0I

3rd Place - #65. I don't give a Financially Unclear Cause, K?
Members: Bee, Starblinky, Ephrayam, daniel1234
"As you can see, this level is a parody and it would have been better if the bg blocks were added earlier, but because they were not, you can think of these as your own children."
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWWRsSlfURbEI

4th Place - #146. Spooky Cookies
Members: Kankurou, Creative, Processor, Thanel, Jojatekok
"Spooky Island"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWUKW1nu-Ta0I

---------------------- Tier 2 Prizes ----------------------

5th Place - #198. LAG crew
Members: lickagoat
"Hellaween"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWUEENJ0vPa0I

6th Place - #79. Team: Bro Co.
Members: Thuggishprune, Drock2308, aoitenshi, Shift, Ugotpwned
"Devilish Terms"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWAEWer0vSa0I

7th Place - #92. SCAR
Members: Addi, Allie, Spiderman, Zacoist, manurthebest
"SCAR - Rocky Horror"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWgbY-CvsEbEI

8th Place - #125. KO crew
Members: Jak, Matt, 0176, Garfield2436
"Sinister"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWYhLyjxPba0I

---------------------- Tier 3 Prizes ----------------------

9th Place - #200. This is not a team
Members: Brawler700, DClevels
"Zombah Pocalypse"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWugCwI-S4a0I

10th Place - #27. cry kid cry
Members: Treejoe4, Express50, Mrboogawesome, Master1, NaztyRushz
"Feel the Fear"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWiTaJ-C8IbEI

11th Place - #1. Lx crew
Members: robban39, ckjr, bliske, ellieangel
"LX spooky castle"
http://beta.everybodyedits.com/games/PWfxrhl6xla0I

12th Place - #168. AE crew
Members: AwzzomeDude,Star
"Trick or Treat"
http://beta.everybodyedits.com/games/PWRysEhScKbEI

------------------------------------------------------------

Congratulations to the winners of the Official Community Halloween Contest!

Still to come, lots of feedback and highlights, so make sure to check back soon.

Epicfish

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

Although my map had a massive trap and shouldn't have been in top 25, I'm looking forward to the top 25 as I haven't got detailed feedback on my mapmaking yet. Thank you everyone who judged/helped .

Off-Topic: Wow, that update messed up Alcatraz, and many other maps, *sigh*.

*EDIT*: Congratulations all winners.

Last edited by Epicfish (Dec 2 2011 1:59:00 pm)

Master1

Member

From: Crait

Joined: 2015-02-15

Posts: 4,452

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

god how the hell did I not get 1st or 2nd :/ well good job guys

---

Shift

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

Lol, second place again. So what happens to teams that won in both series of judging?

EDIT: Congrats to all the new winners! Just remember, we won first.

Last edited by Shift (Dec 2 2011 2:03:50 pm)

Jojatekok

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

---------------------- Tier 1 Prizes ----------------------

4th Place - #146. Spooky Cookies
Members: Kankurou, Creative, Processor, Thanel, Jojatekok
"Spooky Island"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWUKW1nu-Ta0I

EENinja

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

^ Nice

That's certainly more like what I expected to see

Good work EX and others.

mustang

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

god how the hell did I not get 1st or 2nd :/ well good job guys

Hopefully this will be explained once we get the feedback posted. It will take some more time to get all the feedback together and formatted properly, so be on the look out for it.

thecoolguy

Member

Joined: 2015-05-31

Posts: 289

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

no win for me ):, i think it was art based.
i hope i get a better arter next contest

mustang

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

no win for me ):, i think it was art based.
i hope i get a better arter next contest

I'm not sure if this will make you feel better or worse, but Tower Of Moonlight was ranked 13th barely missing the cut for prizes. You definitely had a good map, unfortunately there were many good maps this time around so some couldn't get a prize.

Hopefully when the feedback is posted you can learn from it and come back stronger next contest.

0176

Member

From: Brazil

Joined: 2021-09-05

Posts: 3,174

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

8th Place - #125. KO crew
Members: Jak, Matt, 0176, Garfield2436
"Sinister"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWYhLyjxPba0I

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMYgcS53Ezk[/youtube]

Codfoshie

Member

Joined: 2015-02-15

Posts: 686

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

2nd? Umad Mustang? We are more like 5th haha.

Last edited by Doctor_downes (Dec 2 2011 2:28:00 pm)

Xenonetix

Past Owner

From: Moving on with my life

Joined: 2015-03-07

Posts: 899

Website

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

no win for me ):, i think it was art based.
i hope i get a better arter next contest

Art counted for 30% of the score as the initial post states.

---

Epicfish

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

Quick question: Mustang, seeing as you said which map was 13th, does this mean 13th-25th are ranked and that we'll be told them? If not fair enough, I'm just not 100% sure.

mustang

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

UPDATE - Just a couple of quick announcements clarifying a few issues.

EDIT - First, some of you may wonder why 2ndStory didn't place in the top 26 when they have a very solid map. The problem was RPGMaster2000 overlooked their map, and it didn't appear on the final list until much later. Since they already won a 1st place prize in the official contest, there's no need for us to go back and reevaluate since it won't change their prize, and we apologize for the confusion.

Second, we added one map to our top 25 to make it into a top 26 after sitting down with all of the judges and realizing it had been overlooked. The map is:

#19. Team GD
Members: Jaybm, Demos, Camden1101
"Halloween Castle GD"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PW4A5_AInRa0I

While it didn't place in the top 12, the map did finish strong and will receive the same detailed feedback as the rest of the top 25.

Lastly, we want to give a special honorable mention to the following two maps:

#67 Llama Group
Members: Theditor,Thecoolguy.
"Towers Of Moonlight"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PW72n83hzKa0I

#73. Team: Team Slime
Members: MegaLamb, UltraLamb
"Slime Exploration"
http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWZw1LjUMNbEI

These two teams just barely missed the cut for prizes, and they deserve recognition for almost earning a place in the top 12.

Last edited by mustang (Dec 2 2011 2:56:51 pm)

Zacoist

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

I love you

Ralaina

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

First, some of you may wonder why 2ndStory didn't place in the top 12 when they have a very solid map. The problem was they submitted their map late and only to RPGMaster2000, meaning we could not accept their submission since it was past the deadline.

As a matter of fact we submitted in time, Rpgmaster2000 just happened to overlook it. You can see in the submission-topic that we did infact to do it in time.

http://eeforumify.com/viewtopic.php?id=16177&p=13

Scroll down to around the middle of the page and you will see our submission, the exact time it was submitted:

2011-11-07 23:18:23

48 minutes before Rpgmaster closed the topic, we noticed this and took contact with Rpg and after that he put us on the list.  

So we weren't late as you say, it was just a misstake by Rpg.

But last post on the forums! So see you people around.

Last edited by Ralaina (Dec 2 2011 2:47:21 pm)

Baticon

Guest

Re: Official EE Community Halloween Judging Thread

Did you check the backup teams?