ew old topic

Ernesdo wrote:
Koya wrote:
The contrast hurts to look at
Stop overreacting. There's worse blocks and they're meant to look like that to blend with the water.
He's not overreating, they look bad.

He never said they look bad. The contrast can be something to fix.
And besides, I haven't ever seen you make real graphics, so I don't know if you're the one to judge.

Zoey2070 · 2016-06-25 22:22:26

I like the idea a lot. Kinda reminds me of terraria I guess. I do kind of agree that the contrast looks a bit off; the lights on the block make it kind of washed out and the darks on the bg are kinda eh. they also seem a little bit flat. However, the arches and coral are pretty nice, and I really dig the colors.

Kira wrote:

they look bad

10/10 constructive criticism here

Stagecrew, Badoosh, Gosha, Onjit, Prodigy, Minimania, TaskManager

Guest. · 2016-06-25 23:03:17

Koya wrote:

Ernesdo wrote:
Kira wrote:
Ernesdo wrote:
Koya wrote:
The contrast hurts to look at
Stop overreacting. There's worse blocks and they're meant to look like that to blend with the water.
He's not overreating, they look bad.
He never said they look bad. The contrast can be something to fix.
And besides, I haven't ever seen you make real graphics, so I don't know if you're the one to judge.
Ok, I'll say it now if it will help: they look bad.
It's the contrast, look at the other blocks - even with the checkerboard black and white is grouped.

It doesn't really help.

Once again, it can easily be fixed. If you're honestly going to make such a fuss about it, please change it yourself.

Prodigy · 2016-06-25 23:09:50

If it can be easily fixed then fix it please. I want to see the difference .

some woman, Minimania

SmittyW · 2016-06-25 23:17:49

EE's light source comes from the top-left. Yours is top-right so the blocks should be flipped horizontally. You forgot to apply drop shadow for the solid blocks above the green bg in your ingame image. Add more blocks besides coral that are exclusive to the undersea theme.

I request you drop "Sea" or "Marine" from the pack name. Having both is as redundant as calling it the "Sea Sea Pack"

Guest. · 2016-06-25 23:26:04

SmittyW wrote:

EE's light source comes from the top-left. Yours is top-right so the blocks should be flipped horizontally. You forgot to apply drop shadow for the solid blocks above the green bg in your ingame image. Add more blocks besides coral that are exclusive to the undersea theme.
I request you drop "Sea" or "Marine" from the pack name. Having both is as redundant as calling it the "Sea Sea Pack"

There are also more blocks being worked on, this is being added on to.

Originally called just Marine, but there's 2 meanings to the name. Also, sea pack sounds odd.

Koya · 2016-06-25 23:31:58

Ernesdo wrote:

Koya wrote:
Ernesdo wrote:
Kira wrote:
Ernesdo wrote:
Stop overreacting. There's worse blocks and they're meant to look like that to blend with the water.
He's not overreating, they look bad.
He never said they look bad. The contrast can be something to fix.
And besides, I haven't ever seen you make real graphics, so I don't know if you're the one to judge.
Ok, I'll say it now if it will help: they look bad.
It's the contrast, look at the other blocks - even with the checkerboard black and white is grouped.
It doesn't really help.
Once again, it can easily be fixed. If you're honestly going to make such a fuss about it, please change it yourself.

I was thinking of something like:
rea4t2

It's got sharper edges you like but is balanced.

-

HG isn't talking about me, he's talking about

Also, this is TOOP's underwater/prismarine

MBlood, Prodigy, Stagecrew, some woman, Jedpogi, Lightning Splash, Gosha, Onjit, Luka504, Benje00, Minimania, imgood9, jonhvictor2004sonic

drunkbnu · 2016-06-26 00:22:56

It's a recolor of the gothic pack made by The Toop: Brushfire Graphics

MartenM · 2016-06-26 00:23:47

Include the diver smiley and I'm in

Guest. · 2016-06-26 01:23:46

MartenM wrote:

Include the diver smiley and I'm in

Koya wrote:

I was thinking of something like:
It's got sharper edges you like but is balanced.

That was actually how I planned it! But, I guess it turned into more of a ruins-type pack. This went through a few changes and like I said, I'm working on tweaking it to add shadows, planned blocks, etc. I also hope you know this was more of a test and it shouldn't be taken as seriously as you portray it to be.

Koya wrote:

HG isn't talking about me, he's talking about

I had absolutely no references besides some real life photographs while making this pack.
(Also, of course he would know about that because he makes EE reskins. )

Koya wrote:

Also, this is TOOP's underwater/prismarine

Once again, no references. But that does look neat.

-

Yes Prodigy, woot everything Lord Kira has to say with his totally amazing profile pictures of crippled anime characters and one-look judgement.

Hostage

Stagecrew · 2016-06-26 02:24:42

Ernesdo wrote:

Yes Prodigy, woot everything Lord Kira has to say with his totally amazing profile pictures of crippled anime characters and one-look judgement.

Maybe Prodigy wooted it because he agreed with what he said? If you noticed, he wooted Koya's post as well. Kira said that he agreed with Koya, so of course he would woot Kira's post because he's saying pretty much the same thing. No need to insult two people in one post.

Unau, AmdS, Koya, zioxei, Prodigy, Pingohits, Minimania

some woman · 2016-06-26 03:00:49

Ernesdo wrote:

Yes Prodigy, woot everything Lord Kira has to say with his totally amazing profile pictures of crippled anime characters and one-look judgement.

what happened to that old signature of yours? ">tfw you try to be nice on forums but everyone's a douche to you"?

and yes, the bg does look bad. dark doesn't essentially mean background, needs some contrast removed as well

Kirby · 2016-06-26 08:14:39

Stagecrew wrote:

No need to insult two people in one post.

but two people insulted him in 2 posts?

Awesomenessgood · 2016-06-26 08:29:20

too much minecraft infuence 5/10

Lightning Splash

TaskManager · 2016-06-26 08:34:07

too much contrast on the bg block
What are the corner decorations?

Ernesdo wrote:

coral

WE NEED SOME MEMES ABOUT CORAL
SOME MEMES ABOUT CORAL, CORAL

Koya · 2016-06-26 12:40:41

Stagecrew wrote:

Ernesdo wrote:
http://i.imgur.com/Eli9iU3.png
Yes Prodigy, woot everything Lord Kira has to say with his totally amazing profile pictures of crippled anime characters and one-look judgement.
Maybe Prodigy wooted it because he agreed with what he said? If you noticed, he wooted Koya's post as well. Kira said that he agreed with Koya, so of course he would woot Kira's post because he's saying pretty much the same thing. No need to insult two people in one post.

Ernesdo has been spending too much time in the sea, he's so salty.

Ernesdo wrote:

Koya wrote:
HG isn't talking about me, he's talking about
http://i.imgur.com/cOxvglT.png
I had absolutely no references besides some real life photographs while making this pack.
(Also, of course he would know about that because he makes EE reskins. )
Koya wrote:
Also, this is TOOP's underwater/prismarine
http://i.imgur.com/v41ym9j.png
Once again, no references. But that does look neat.

I don't see the correlation that HG was talking about your work, but in IRC that's what he said;

zioxei, Prodigy

Guest. · 2016-06-26 14:14:55

some man wrote:

Ernesdo wrote:
http://i.imgur.com/Eli9iU3.png
Yes Prodigy, woot everything Lord Kira has to say with his totally amazing profile pictures of crippled anime characters and one-look judgement.
what happened to that old signature of yours? ">tfw you try to be nice on forums but everyone's a douche to you"?
and yes, the bg does look bad. dark doesn't essentially mean background, needs some contrast removed as well

I'm done being nice if everyone's going to act so hostile like this. If you think you can just insult me like that and let me take it, you're very mistaken.

Have you read the other posts?
I said I was going to make some changes.

Stagecrew wrote:

Ernesdo wrote:
http://i.imgur.com/Eli9iU3.png
Yes Prodigy, woot everything Lord Kira has to say with his totally amazing profile pictures of crippled anime characters and one-look judgement.
Stagecrew wrote:
Ernesdo wrote:
Yes Prodigy, woot everything Lord Kira has to say with his totally amazing profile pictures of crippled anime characters and one-look judgement.
Maybe Prodigy wooted it because he agreed with what he said? If you noticed, he wooted Koya's post as well. Kira said that he agreed with Koya, so of course he would woot Kira's post because he's saying pretty much the same thing. No need to insult two people in one post.

Actually, no. Prodigy is basically Kira's underling and Kira hates me even though we've really never met. Don't just assume these things without confirmation.

Koya wrote:

Ernesdo has been spending too much time in the sea, he's so salty.

get out.

Also, I don't read the title and see "Insult Ernesdo" so if you're here to do that -- Kira -- then get out.
You also aren't helping with saying "ITS BADD!!!1one!!exclimationpoint", that's not constructive criticism at all. So if you're here to do that -- Koya -- then get out. If you want to use real constructive criticism, tell me what can be changed without saying "oMG ITZ SO BAD!! XDD" or change it yourself.
A ton of you are also off topic, so get out as well. Note that this is in Graphics Suggestions, not Spam Suggestions.

jbbill · 2016-06-26 14:36:32

okay one thing that disturbs me with this is the brightness of the block. Imo it should be a bit darker and a bit less green(goes for all the blocks btw) also most of the time the see floor is meant to be pitch black as you cant see anything unless in

Kira · 2016-06-26 14:36:36

Truth hurts, chill man. I just said they were bad because they don't fit EE in any way, The blocks / Background looks pratically the same which can mislead the player, as said previously the contrast is way too high. Try making the block more simple, more EE like.

Koya, Prodigy, Unau, Minimania

Guest. · 2016-06-26 15:40:40

Kira wrote:

Truth hurts, chill man. I just said they were bad because they don't fit EE in any way, The blocks / Background looks pratically the same which can mislead the player, as said previously the contrast is way too high. Try making the block more simple, more EE like.

supreme overlord and everybody edits sensation kiraninja it's easy to spot a background from a block what are you on about

oh and there goes prodigy again how surprising

Official Everybody Edits Forums

#1 2016-06-25 19:04:18, last edited by Guest. (2017-08-30 23:23:48)

ew old topic

#2 2016-06-25 20:19:01

Re: ew old topic

#3 2016-06-25 20:43:10

Re: ew old topic

#4 2016-06-25 21:17:44

Re: ew old topic

#5 2016-06-25 21:45:00

Re: ew old topic

#6 2016-06-25 22:14:23

Re: ew old topic

#7 2016-06-25 22:22:26

Re: ew old topic

#8 2016-06-25 23:03:17

Re: ew old topic

#9 2016-06-25 23:09:50

Re: ew old topic

#10 2016-06-25 23:17:49

Re: ew old topic

#11 2016-06-25 23:26:04, last edited by Guest. (2016-06-25 23:28:03)

Re: ew old topic

#12 2016-06-25 23:31:58, last edited by Koya (2016-06-26 00:32:44)

Re: ew old topic

HG isn't talking about me, he's talking about

#13 2016-06-26 00:22:56

Re: ew old topic

#14 2016-06-26 00:23:47

Re: ew old topic

#15 2016-06-26 01:23:46, last edited by Guest. (2016-06-26 01:34:53)

Re: ew old topic

#16 2016-06-26 02:24:42, last edited by Stagecrew (2016-06-26 02:27:01)

Re: ew old topic

#17 2016-06-26 03:00:49, last edited by some woman (2016-06-26 03:06:33)

Re: ew old topic

#18 2016-06-26 08:14:39

Re: ew old topic

#19 2016-06-26 08:29:20

Re: ew old topic

#20 2016-06-26 08:34:07

Re: ew old topic

#21 2016-06-26 12:40:41

Re: ew old topic

#22 2016-06-26 14:14:55

Re: ew old topic

#23 2016-06-26 14:36:32

Re: ew old topic

#24 2016-06-26 14:36:36

Re: ew old topic

#25 2016-06-26 15:40:40, last edited by Guest. (2016-06-26 16:26:48)

Re: ew old topic

Board footer