Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

TaskManager · 2016-02-13 21:13:33

SmittyW. wrote:

we don't get any other claims soon, we might have to lynch either you or maxi to get any info.

you clearly try to find out everyone's role and try to push attention away from yourself

Processor · 2016-02-13 21:20:25

I am a unique snowflake <3

Zoey2070 wrote:

proc pls explain exactly why i'm so heavily scum besides based on activity, because i can think of a pretty good reason for laying low besides being scum.

Assuming: *can't

Reluctance to persuade the town's goal. This is mostly about the way you present facts, the general negative attitude you have in this game is very dumb.
In Game 3 you MADE an effort to contribute. Game 3 was also the only game where you were town.
Now you are just back to being just like you were in game 2.

Zoey2070 wrote:

or maybe because literally every time i post, i'm attacked for it not being "important" enough? why should i post if i have nothing really valuable to say? my goal is and always has been to live as long as possible. I don't switch into in-it-to-win-it mode until way late. hi guys i've spent the last four mafia games being mostly apathetic. (also i do this on TOS too) (also i p much forced myself to stop being lazy and actually post g3)
(also i pretty much forget it every single time until someone posts and i see the notification from gregbot)

Bla bla bla, that is just blank text with no content at all which I am just going to ignore.

Actually, I just found something in there: A CONTRADICTION!!!!!!!

Zoey2070 wrote:

why should i post if i have nothing really valuable to say?

So it's ok to not have anything to say?

Zoey2070 wrote:

o wow u have nothing to say? completely suspicious

Then you go an accuse Bobithan and SmittyW for the same reason?!

And another thing:

Zoey2070 wrote:

my goal is and always has been to live as long as possible.

"hai guys I'm scum but don't lynch me"
This is what a scum wants. You just told us directly, thanks!

Zoey2070 wrote:

maybe proc and pyro are buddied. idk. kinda seems that way though.

What gives you this impression?

Oh wait why am I even talking with a scum about this....

Zoey2070 wrote:

woah for a second i was gonna say there's no way you replied that fast to my post gg

Ahahahahha how cute

RhazzleFrazzle · 2016-02-13 21:26:33

Vote count:

Processor:Maxi123
Zoey2070:Processsor

7 votes needed for majority

SmittyW · 2016-02-13 21:28:31

maxi123 wrote:

SmittyW. wrote:
we don't get any other claims soon, we might have to lynch either you or maxi to get any info.
you clearly try to find out everyone's role and try to push attention away from yourself

Isn't that the point of the game? In my case, I know what my role is so I want to spend more time interrogating others. Also don't get me wrong but I don't want to spare you just to get on your good side. I legitimately think that we can find a better suspect and lynch them instead, but if we don't nail a decision soon then I think lynching one of you is the second best option. I hope you understand.

SmittyW · 2016-02-13 21:32:54

Also forgive me for any lack of input. This is my first EE Mafia game. I realize I should be taking charge too but a lot of you are veterans and know better than I how some people react in certain situations.

Evilbunny · 2016-02-13 21:38:45

Processor wrote:

Actually, I just found something in there: A CONTRADICTION!!!!!!!
Zoey2070 wrote:
why should i post if i have nothing really valuable to say?
So it's ok to not have anything to say?
Zoey2070 wrote:
o wow u have nothing to say? completely suspicious
Then you go an accuse Bobithan and SmittyW for the same reason?!

that was a joke. She was saying that she is being unfairly pointed out while they weren't.

Processor wrote:

And another thing:
Zoey2070 wrote:
my goal is and always has been to live as long as possible.
"hai guys I'm scum but don't lynch me"
This is what a scum wants. You just told us directly, thanks!

this is what everybody wants. Sarcasm or not, this should be completely ignored.

Proc you can't complain about Zoey's attitude when you make a post like that^.

7 votes for a majority seems incredibly difficult with how divided we are and will be.

Today has been a lot of speculation about night events with too many variables and not enough information. And of course, because this is mafia, whatever information we do have is likely to be false and intentionally misleading. All of these self-aware-meta-mindgames posts look nice on paper, but they don't really get us anywhere.

SmittyW · 2016-02-13 21:45:31

Processor you are taking a lot of what Zoey said in the first half out of context and merely nitpicking.

Processor wrote:

Zoey2070 wrote:
why should i post if i have nothing really valuable to say?
So it's ok to not have anything to say?

That doesn't even make sense. She can't help it if she doesn't have any info.

Zoey2070 wrote:

o wow u have nothing to say? completely suspicious

I think that was sarcasm.

Zoey2070 wrote:

my goal is and always has been to live as long as possible.

These were the only bad choice of words. This isn't a free-for-all. If you are town, your allegiance is to the town and not to yourself.

Zoey2070 · 2016-02-13 21:57:58

Processor wrote:

I am a unique snowflake <3
Zoey2070 wrote:
proc pls explain exactly why i'm so heavily scum besides based on activity, because i can think of a pretty good reason for laying low besides being scum.
Assuming: *can't
Reluctance to persuade the town's goal. This is mostly about the way you present facts, the general negative attitude you have in this game is very dumb.
In Game 3 you MADE an effort to contribute. Game 3 was also the only game where you were town.
Now you are just back to being just like you were in game 2.

NEVER ASSUME BB

game 3 was the only game where i wasn't a PR
mlg rekt

procbb wrote:

Zoey2070 wrote:
why should i post if i have nothing really valuable to say?
So it's ok to not have anything to say?
Zoey2070 wrote:
o wow u have nothing to say? completely suspicious
Then you go an accuse Bobithan and SmittyW for the same reason?!

sarcasm bb

proc wrote:

And another thing:
Zoey2070 wrote:
my goal is and always has been to live as long as possible.
"hai guys I'm scum but don't lynch me"
This is what a scum wants. You just told us directly, thanks!
Zoey2070 wrote:
maybe proc and pyro are buddied. idk. kinda seems that way though.
What gives you this impression?
Oh wait why am I even talking with a scum about this....
Zoey2070 wrote:
woah for a second i was gonna say there's no way you replied that fast to my post gg
Ahahahahha how cute

a) what. look, if i make it near the end, i consider it a win.

b) why are you even dismissing that. i'll write more about my reads on you when i feel like it, but you'll just dismiss them because confirmation bias, right?

c) i know u are but what am i

Processor · 2016-02-13 21:58:04

SmittyW. wrote:

That doesn't even make sense. She can't help it if she doesn't have any info.

It was part of a longer statement. This first part of my statement was sarcastic.

SmittyW. wrote:

I think that was sarcasm.

Except it SERIOUSLY IS suspicious if people just say "hi guis I have nothing to say, dont prod me, but I wont make ANY EFFORT WHATSOEVER TO HELP YOU I WILL JUST SIT HERE AND LET MAFIA WIN".

You might think she is being sarcastic, but if you don't take it for sarcasm it makes perfect sense and is a statement I will agree with. By lurking you are making it easy for mafia to hide between the crowd. You gotta stand out or you get policy lynched.

Even if her statement was sarcastic, it proves my other point. Zoey is being the opposite of a pro-town member. How does she want to win this game by accepting the fact that half the members of the game are just sitting here doing nothing? I have to believe that she doesn't want town to win. It's the only explanation to all this.

TaskManager · 2016-02-13 22:04:09

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Processor:Maxi123

???
i unvoted
!unvote
ill do it again i guess :l

Processor · 2016-02-13 22:04:39

Zoey2070 wrote:

what. look, if i make it near the end, i consider it a win.

This is not how you win mafia.

Zoey2070 wrote:

i'll write more about my reads on you when i feel like it, but you'll just dismiss them because confirmation bias, right?

Do you know what confbias is? Nobody mentioned pyro and I buddying before. Who are you going to confirm?

I am going to assume you really didn't have a single reason to accuse me of that. Just tossing accusations around, very towny, very towny.

Your attitude is becoming more and more malicious.

I'd vote for you again if I could.
!vote Zoey2070

@SmittyW: Do you seriously think Zoey's behavior is ok? Don't you see ANYTHING wrong with it?

Processor · 2016-02-13 22:08:05

Zoey2070 wrote:

what. look, if i make it near the end, i consider it a win.

I am just speechless. This is the definition of gamethrowing.
(@RhazzleFrazzle: REPORT REPORT PLEASE REPLACE ZOEY FOR GODS SAKE)

Processor · 2016-02-13 22:08:35

(@RhazzleFrazzle: Get your votes right, W24 voted for Maxi123, Maxi123 didn't vote for anybody)

TaskManager · 2016-02-13 22:12:26

wtf zoey why do you even play this really

SmittyW · 2016-02-13 22:14:58

Well, um, well... yeah.

!vote Zoey2070

TaskManager · 2016-02-13 22:16:57

SmittyW. wrote:

Well, um, well... yeah.
!vote Zoey2070

now you just again followed proc because that was the best thing you thought would be to look more like town

Processor · 2016-02-13 22:20:49

SmittyW. wrote:

!vote Zoey2070

Wow I am not that blind then!

maxi123 wrote:

now you just again followed proc because that was the best thing you thought would be to look more like town

Now you're nagging around for no reason. Voting out of nowhere is suspicious, but Smitty and I just had a convo about Zoey. Look a few posts behind this one. I literally asked Smitty to vote for her.

Zoey2070 · 2016-02-13 22:21:10

mfw i go afk to eat and get voted up

Processor wrote:

Except it SERIOUSLY IS suspicious if people just say "hi guis I have nothing to say, dont prod me, but I wont make ANY EFFORT WHATSOEVER TO HELP YOU I WILL JUST SIT HERE AND LET MAFIA WIN".
You might think she is being sarcastic, but if you don't take it for sarcasm it makes perfect sense and is a statement I will agree with. By lurking you are making it easy for mafia to hide between the crowd. You gotta stand out or you get policy lynched.
Even if her statement was sarcastic, it proves my other point. Zoey is being the opposite of a pro-town member. How does she want to win this game by accepting the fact that half the members of the game are just sitting here doing nothing? I have to believe that she doesn't want town to win. It's the only explanation to all this.

how am i accepting of the fact that pretty much everyone is an afker? and let's be real, town never wins these games.

maxi123 wrote:

wtf zoey why do you even play this really

no

SmittyW. wrote:

Well, um, well... yeah.
!vote Zoey2070

i'm very proud of your ability to think for yourself. look, i know no one's going to believe me because processor's very persuasive, but i'm legit 100% town.

pls give me a little while to make some more posts before majority kthx

Zoey2070 · 2016-02-13 22:21:57

mfw two posts ninjaing the smitty thing

Processor · 2016-02-13 22:24:19

Also I just realized that I have no reason to believe that Calicara is town.

The first assumption came with the suspicions I had about Creature. Since he is looking rather town to me right now, I am going to move Calicara to the yellow area in my reads list. She could turn out to be mafia just as likely as she is to be town. If she turns out to be mafia, Creature and maxi are both town.

I don't think we need to speculate about Calicara much more than this though, her fate is already decided.

Processor · 2016-02-13 22:28:03

Zoey2070 wrote:

and let's be real, town never wins these games.

I was there in game one and I won that game.

I'm just going to ignore the "no" before I explode.

Zoey2070 wrote:

pls give me a little while to make some more posts before majority kthx

Wish granted. I'll unvote if it comes to it.

Anak · 2016-02-13 22:38:14

Processor wrote:

Zoey2070 wrote:
what. look, if i make it near the end, i consider it a win.
I am just speechless. This is the definition of gamethrowing.
(@RhazzleFrazzle: REPORT REPORT PLEASE REPLACE ZOEY FOR GODS SAKE)

?? Why such an exaggeration, she was not being serious, and she meant a personal win for herself.

I'm not saying I agree with her, uh, strategy, but you're being rather over the top about this

SmittyW · 2016-02-13 22:38:52

maxi123 wrote:

SmittyW. wrote:
Well, um, well... yeah.
!vote Zoey2070
now you just again followed proc because that was the best thing you thought would be to look more like town

The whole time you accuse me of acting like a townie. Where do you actually draw the line that I am a townie?

SmittyW · 2016-02-13 22:43:24

Zoey2070 wrote:

SmittyW. wrote:
Well, um, well... yeah.
!vote Zoey2070
i'm very proud of your ability to think for yourself. look, i know no one's going to believe me because processor's very persuasive, but i'm legit 100% town.
pls give me a little while to make some more posts before majority kthx

I was actually trying to defend you but then you just threw the game. Idk if it's sarcasm again but maybe you should try acting more supportive by showing you are serious.

W24 · 2016-02-13 23:06:06

About hostage. Most of his posts here aren't contributing anything to the discussion here, so I'm a bit suspicious about him. Anyone else think the same?

Official Everybody Edits Forums

#251 2016-02-13 21:13:33

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#252 2016-02-13 21:20:25

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#253 2016-02-13 21:26:33

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#254 2016-02-13 21:28:31

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#255 2016-02-13 21:32:54

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#256 2016-02-13 21:38:45

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#257 2016-02-13 21:45:31

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#258 2016-02-13 21:57:58

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#259 2016-02-13 21:58:04

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#260 2016-02-13 22:04:09

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#261 2016-02-13 22:04:39

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#262 2016-02-13 22:08:05

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#263 2016-02-13 22:08:35

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#264 2016-02-13 22:12:26

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#265 2016-02-13 22:14:58

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#266 2016-02-13 22:16:57

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#267 2016-02-13 22:20:49

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#268 2016-02-13 22:21:10

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#269 2016-02-13 22:21:57

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#270 2016-02-13 22:24:19

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#271 2016-02-13 22:28:03

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#272 2016-02-13 22:38:14

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#273 2016-02-13 22:38:52

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#274 2016-02-13 22:43:24

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

#275 2016-02-13 23:06:06

Re: Mafia 4 game thread (Day 2)

Board footer