Official Everybody Edits Forums

Tachyonic

Guest

Re: Astronaut smiley

Right so i've settled this, ignore anything i've said, I want any feedback now, just explain why you think its bad! If its REALLY REALLY REALLY bad, I want to know!

1. It doesn't fit the theme/shape of EE smilies.
2. All you did was edit minor parts of the Robot smiley.

Iced

Guest

Re: Astronaut smiley

Ok, i'll improve next time.

ABC Boy

Guest

Re: Astronaut smiley

Well, I would like to edit yours. Maybe it will be improved!
EDIT:

Sorry, but the robot smiley didn't fit the smiley.

Last edited by ABC Boy (Aug 2 2012 5:51:54 am)

hisss

Guest

Re: Astronaut smiley

Yellowish orange visor would be good and edit the dimensions.[not change edit this is everybodyedits]

collectionshower

Guest

Re: Astronaut smiley

For someone who designed the Robot Smiley, you should do better than this. I mean, it's good, but try to make it more original, and not use something you've done in the past and edit it a bit. For example, I try not to reuse my smileys and alter them SLIGHTLY. You're a great graphic designer, who designed a nice robot, now why don't you design an Astronaut without using the robot?

Iced

Guest

Re: Astronaut smiley

collectionshower has made a good point, consider this smiley closed, thanks for that collectionshower, it made me feel better

Kirby

Member

Joined: 2015-04-04

Posts: 4,307

Re: Astronaut smiley

honestly, koto this isnt criticism anymore, not its turning into plain rudeness

you dont say "it sucks" your supposed to say "its alright" or "i dont really like it because ____"

at least post a legit reason

i personally think you should change the color of the visor to a darker gray and round the edges a bit, but otherwise, good work!