Official Everybody Edits Forums

DK Levels

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Warning DK is about to rant.

i thought it would be fun to judge people

Very off-putting and that sounds so rude...
Besides your 'forum member judging' is flawed. Basically, I read all the descriptions and all you are saying is you are judging on:
Post count, Reputation, Grammar and how they respond.
This isn't judging the forum member, it's judging their presentation as one. What it should really be about is How responsive you are, What you are like within the community, Do you help?, Do you relate to the topic?, Do you contribute towards things (e.g a project aka A level, room, whatever), Are you active within the game?, How do you behave within the community? There is so much more I could name... but you hopefully get the point.

"Reputation" is basically some number thing that apparently tells us what 'rank' a person is within a community, say for example you are active, you get into debates and get involved within a topic, like a good forumer does (IMO) and sadly a lot of people might disagree with your argument for something and therefore -rep you, it can't be removed because it's a valid -rep.
Also, if you look at my rep, or anyone elses rep for that matter, a lot of pluses are pointless, I got several for having a cute panda sig, then I got one for my 100th...   You yourself Sythe5665 have TONS of reps all due to the rep game. Are you seriously judging rep?

Also, why the **** judge grammar out of all things?? Sure it is annoying When People Type Like This or confuse 'Your' and 'You're' but seriously???
I admit, I have a huge habit of incorrect punctuation and grammar sometimes due to habits that I've had since a very young age, and it goes the same for a lot of people, it's all a part of presentation. It's the content and the actual point of the post that matters. (Obviously we want it to make sense and be readable, but judging grammar is a bit far ESPECIALLY since not a lot of people are English speakers for one and a lot are in their school years still.)

And last thing to complain about :

109-110: Technically, only Different55 can get this rank, and that's if he has a perfect/near perfect rep and gets 95+ rating on post rating and info represented, as well as no forum games/grammar mistakes. Basically, you'd have to be an extremely lucky Different55.

WHY THE *&&^%%(*&^%$$ HAVE A RANK NO ONE CAN PRACTICALLY GET?
It's basically like saying
"Oh by the way, I have a secret!"
- "What is it?"
"I can't say."
- " -.- "

Congratulate yourself now if you read through all of that! Have some cake ^^

Different55

Forum Admin

Joined: 2015-02-07

Posts: 16,575

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Are you using the same spreadsheet as Jad?

if you mean the ranks? yes...

No... I actually meant spreadsheet. Jad used a spreadsheet (Microsoft Excel) to calculate everyone's score.

---

"Sometimes failing a leap of faith is better than inching forward"
- ShinsukeIto

Sythe5665

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Are you using the same spreadsheet as Jad?

if you mean the ranks? yes...

No... I actually meant spreadsheet. Jad used a spreadsheet (Microsoft Excel) to calculate everyone's score.

Oh... Well I'm pretty good at doing this kind of stuff in my head. I basically just read everybody's posts and figure out if they post rude comments or good comments and kind of stuff most of the time, and then I just try to figure out their reputation (like if they have a reputation for posting rude comments or grammar mistakes) then I give them a rank!

Warning DK is about to rant.

i thought it would be fun to judge people

Very off-putting and that sounds so rude...
Besides your 'forum member judging' is flawed. Basically, I read all the descriptions and all you are saying is you are judging on:
Post count, Reputation, Grammar and how they respond.
This isn't judging the forum member, it's judging their presentation as one. What it should really be about is How responsive you are, What you are like within the community, Do you help?, Do you relate to the topic?, Do you contribute towards things (e.g a project aka A level, room, whatever), Are you active within the game?, How do you behave within the community? There is so much more I could name... but you hopefully get the point.

"Reputation" is basically some number thing that apparently tells us what 'rank' a person is within a community, say for example you are active, you get into debates and get involved within a topic, like a good forumer does (IMO) and sadly a lot of people might disagree with your argument for something and therefore -rep you, it can't be removed because it's a valid -rep.
Also, if you look at my rep, or anyone elses rep for that matter, a lot of pluses are pointless, I got several for having a cute panda sig, then I got one for my 100th...   You yourself Sythe5665 have TONS of reps all due to the rep game. Are you seriously judging rep?

Also, why the **** judge grammar out of all things?? Sure it is annoying When People Type Like This or confuse 'Your' and 'You're' but seriously???
I admit, I have a huge habit of incorrect punctuation and grammar sometimes due to habits that I've had since a very young age, and it goes the same for a lot of people, it's all a part of presentation. It's the content and the actual point of the post that matters. (Obviously we want it to make sense and be readable, but judging grammar is a bit far ESPECIALLY since not a lot of people are English speakers for one and a lot are in their school years still.)

And last thing to complain about :

109-110: Technically, only Different55 can get this rank, and that's if he has a perfect/near perfect rep and gets 95+ rating on post rating and info represented, as well as no forum games/grammar mistakes. Basically, you'd have to be an extremely lucky Different55.

WHY THE *&&^%%(*&^%$$ HAVE A RANK NO ONE CAN PRACTICALLY GET?
It's basically like saying
"Oh by the way, I have a secret!"
- "What is it?"
"I can't say."
- " -.- "

Congratulate yourself now if you read through all of that! Have some cake ^^

I didn't make the ranks, talk to JadElClemends about that, and you are right about how I said that it might be fun to judge people, I guess I wasn't thinking strait

Last edited by Sythe5665 (Jan 12 2012 6:02:47 pm)

JadElClemens

Member

From: Colorado, USA

Joined: 2015-02-15

Posts: 4,559

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Are you using the same spreadsheet as Jad?

if you mean the ranks? yes...

No... I actually meant spreadsheet. Jad used a spreadsheet (Microsoft Excel) to calculate everyone's score.

Nah, man. My spreadsheet downloads all have passwords on them, even though the final raking spreadsheets are fully operational and not locked... silly me.

I'm just gonna say that I approve of this topic, but not necessarily endorse it. I like that you'll be giving ratings to people that I perhaps didn't get to (and it was a long list), but I plan on re-starting when I get some free time.

---

I hate tall signatures.

Sythe5665

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

I just wanted people to be rated by another person also, btw do you want me to rate you?

xputnameherex

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Warning DK is about to rant.

i thought it would be fun to judge people

Very off-putting and that sounds so rude...
Besides your 'forum member judging' is flawed. Basically, I read all the descriptions and all you are saying is you are judging on:
Post count, Reputation, Grammar and how they respond.
This isn't judging the forum member, it's judging their presentation as one. What it should really be about is How responsive you are, What you are like within the community, Do you help?, Do you relate to the topic?, Do you contribute towards things (e.g a project aka A level, room, whatever), Are you active within the game?, How do you behave within the community? There is so much more I could name... but you hopefully get the point.

"Reputation" is basically some number thing that apparently tells us what 'rank' a person is within a community, say for example you are active, you get into debates and get involved within a topic, like a good forumer does (IMO) and sadly a lot of people might disagree with your argument for something and therefore -rep you, it can't be removed because it's a valid -rep.
Also, if you look at my rep, or anyone elses rep for that matter, a lot of pluses are pointless, I got several for having a cute panda sig, then I got one for my 100th...   You yourself Sythe5665 have TONS of reps all due to the rep game. Are you seriously judging rep?

Also, why the **** judge grammar out of all things?? Sure it is annoying When People Type Like This or confuse 'Your' and 'You're' but seriously???
I admit, I have a huge habit of incorrect punctuation and grammar sometimes due to habits that I've had since a very young age, and it goes the same for a lot of people, it's all a part of presentation. It's the content and the actual point of the post that matters. (Obviously we want it to make sense and be readable, but judging grammar is a bit far ESPECIALLY since not a lot of people are English speakers for one and a lot are in their school years still.)

And last thing to complain about :

109-110: Technically, only Different55 can get this rank, and that's if he has a perfect/near perfect rep and gets 95+ rating on post rating and info represented, as well as no forum games/grammar mistakes. Basically, you'd have to be an extremely lucky Different55.

WHY THE *&&^%%(*&^%$$ HAVE A RANK NO ONE CAN PRACTICALLY GET?
It's basically like saying
"Oh by the way, I have a secret!"
- "What is it?"
"I can't say."
- " -.- "

Congratulate yourself now if you read through all of that! Have some cake ^^

I was gonna say almost everything you said there (and a bit more), but then I was lazy. :/

plat aka kingpooultra

Member

Joined: 2017-05-27

Posts: 3,873

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

I like the outcome I got for the judging. I do flame sometimes, but it's usually not my intentions. Sometimes my anger issues gets a hold of me.

Thank you though.

Muffin

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

I can haz top of list?

Sythe5665

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

I can haz top of list?

Uh... YEAH!

Different55

Forum Admin

Joined: 2015-02-07

Posts: 16,575

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

if you mean the ranks? yes...

No... I actually meant spreadsheet. Jad used a spreadsheet (Microsoft Excel) to calculate everyone's score.

Nah, man. My spreadsheet downloads all have passwords on them, even though the final raking spreadsheets are fully operational and not locked... silly me.

Not password protected at all. I have a fully working copy in my downloads folder

---

"Sometimes failing a leap of faith is better than inching forward"
- ShinsukeIto

RhazzleFrazzle

Member

Joined: 2015-11-10

Posts: 4,260

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

can you rate me?

NikK

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Are you using the same spreadsheet as Jad?

if you mean the ranks? yes...

He meant the excel spreadsheet you use to judge people.

F1redragon

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Rate me!

Sythe5665

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Oh my gosh the 1st thing all of you should be saying when you post here is rate me! It makes me confused!

Last edited by Sythe5665 (Jan 13 2012 8:47:35 am)

DK Levels

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

I didn't make the ranks, talk to JadElClemends about that, and you are right about how I said that it might be fun to judge people, I guess I wasn't thinking strait

Yes but it is your thread, you didn't have to follow what JadElClemends did, you could have set up your own ranks of judging, which would make this one different to the other one, so people that previously got judged, could get judged again, but on (IMO) better criteria.

Sythe5665

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

I didn't make the ranks, talk to JadElClemends about that, and you are right about how I said that it might be fun to judge people, I guess I wasn't thinking strait

Yes but it is your thread, you didn't have to follow what JadElClemends did, you could have set up your own ranks of judging, which would make this one different to the other one, so people that previously got judged, could get judged again, but on (IMO) better criteria.

I liked his ranks, plus, I wouldn't be able to make very good ones myself but hey, don't waste your time arguing! Anyway, I'll change it so that it's POSSIBLE for someone else to get 108 or higher but highly unlikely. Someone other then diff will make it k?

ktostam450

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Can you rate me, please?

Sythe5665

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Yeah I'll rate you too!

DylanDaSkater

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Rate Me? :3

Vulcan

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

I'll go

Master1

Member

From: Crait

Joined: 2015-02-15

Posts: 4,452

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Can you rate me? :>

---

JadElClemens

Member

From: Colorado, USA

Joined: 2015-02-15

Posts: 4,559

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

http://eeforumify.com/viewtopic.php?pid=295844#p295844
Please consider.

Also, seeing as you took the ratings/descriptions from my topic, I approve of this less. Nothing I can do, though.

Anyway, go to the link I provided and consider what I say there. It'd be best.
---

better criteria.

Please explain. I love criticism. I actually asked for it in my last topic. What's wrong with my ratings, what needs to be done differently?

Last edited by JadElClemens (Jan 14 2012 8:16:13 pm)

---

I hate tall signatures.

DK Levels

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

I didn't make the ranks, talk to JadElClemends about that, and you are right about how I said that it might be fun to judge people, I guess I wasn't thinking strait

Yes but it is your thread, you didn't have to follow what JadElClemends did, you could have set up your own ranks of judging, which would make this one different to the other one, so people that previously got judged, could get judged again, but on (IMO) better criteria.

I liked his ranks, plus, I wouldn't be able to make very good ones myself but hey, don't waste your time arguing! Anyway, I'll change it so that it's POSSIBLE for someone else to get 108 or higher but highly unlikely. Someone other then diff will make it k?

I wasn't arguing to start with, I was simply expressing my opinion on this, and replying to your posts just like you did to mine. Also, I kinda hardly visit this forum, so I'm hardly wasting my time...
It wasn't about Different being right on top, it was about having a basically pointless rank...
My argument was simply saying that in my opinion you shouldn't judge 'Forum members' on the current criteria (Again, this is just my opinion, obviously people will either agree or disagree, and that's fine with me)

Please explain. I love criticism. I actually asked for it in my last topic. What's wrong with my ratings, what needs to be done differently?

This isn't judging the forum member, it's judging their presentation as one. What it should really be about is How responsive you are, What you are like within the community, Do you help?, Do you relate to the topic?, Do you contribute towards things (e.g a project aka A level, room, whatever), Are you active within the game?, How do you behave within the community? There is so much more I could name... but you hopefully get the point.

TheGreenTroll

Guest

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

Do me

Kirby

Member

Joined: 2015-04-04

Posts: 4,307

Re: Sythe's Forum Member Judgeing

I only have a bad rep because I do backwards rep (-reps are good for me, +reps are bad for me.)

You made that signature after your bad reputation, you have bad reputation because people don't like annoying posts..

On topic: Can you judge me?

Oh, and shouldn't this be in forum discussion since it doesn't really have anything to do with everybody edits?