Do you think I could just leave this part blank and it'd be okay? We're just going to replace the whole thing with a header image anyway, right?
You are not logged in.
It is certainly terrifying that it is so easy to forgot about most suggestions as time passes
It is really sad that all those good ideas are not even listed in a to-do pipeline list in staff
It seems that there is any list from the staff to remember and keep all glorious ideas safe
Trello would be a nice tool for the Staff to accomplish that purpose
There were some lists made by the community itself using trello, containing graphic and game suggestions, It seems that most of those has been deleted or trolled
Some of those were:
https://trello.com/b/3jeyQFEC/everybody-edits-ideas (This does not contain all suggestions ever made)
https://trello.com/b/iragsoFz/everybody-edits-changelog (This was made by NVD, but does not contain all suggestions ever made either)
https://trello.com/b/04nLI3cZ/everybody-edits-worlds (This is a list by Sirjosh and Jesse probably, but sadly EE worlds has been abandoned, but might as well fit for EE, this does not have all suggestions ever made either)
Not quite sure if there is any other suggestion collection out there with ideas for EE (Most likely to be as well an uncomplete collection, but helps in case it has original ideas not listed in the EE forums)
P.S.1: I listed while in the staff all-EE-time graphic suggestions from 2009 to 2020ish as the staff didn´t had it either, but a list for game-suggestions means a lot of more complexity and explanation per idea. (The complete graphic collection list is in the forum topic "Graphics ideas topic" in the Graphic suggestion forum, Could update it if needed btw)
P.S.2: It would be very cool if there is actually an active and in-use trello list or similar that the current staff owns and is using for developing EEU, it would be a nice thing to know they are actually tracking suggestions and ideas from 2009 to 2020ish, but it is most likely to not be the case
Suggestion:
In conclusion it seems that EE does not have any list that have the whole track of suggestion ideas from 2009 to 2020ish (A list that should have to-do / discarded / to be discussed / pending / etc)
(Suggestion for it: Joke suggestions would be discarded, the trello could be managed by EE members or the staff itself (The admin should be an EE staff anyway) (I think even if it is managed by EE members, the EE staff should have a copy of the board secured from trolls))
List 1.: Here all the ideas are posted and organized, the ideas here should never be deleted (Unless it is with no doubt a joke suggestion)
List 2.: It is a separated list that is only for staff members, it would contain the ideas /to be discussed/pending/discarded/to-do/ this to avoid leaking to the community future plans for the game (Staff-Only Trello board)
The suggestion here is to track every single suggestion made (that is not a joke) even if the idea sounds a little hard to implement or if the idea is not realy a priority or even if the idea is disliked or even consider to be a "bad" idea
Because one team might consider an idea to be bad, but then other team consider it to be god and guess what happen next, it becomes the best idea ever, so I consider to never discard a single idea even if it is bad unless it is a joke suggestion with no doubt (If doubt if it is or not a joke suggestion the add it to the list anyway)
The ideas are kept safe and when the staff want to work with one of those it is taken from the idea list to the to-do list, so the staff can work on it considering the pipeline tasks
The discarded panel (For discarded ideas) could be re-visited later on by new staff or by the staff itself to re-consider ideas later on
Those official boards would allow to avoid ideas to be forgotten in the oblivion ever again
not gonana read the post btu the title is a good one some board to collect suggestions and listing good a nd ba dones
thanks hg for making this much better and ty for my avatar aswell
Offline
a nd ba dones is so cool
[ Started around 1733251501.298 - Generated in 0.371 seconds, 13 queries executed - Memory usage: 1.38 MiB (Peak: 1.48 MiB) ]