Official Everybody Edits Forums

Kira

Member

Joined: 2019-04-22

Posts: 1,346

Mafia 23 discussion

We should have a new rule in mafia 23 which is the following

- if your iq is lower than 20 you are not allowed to join

Would make the game much more enjoyable

Jorc

Member

From: Petoria

Joined: 2016-03-20

Posts: 1,351

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

Amazing suggestion, should be added.

GreenyMix

Formerly Snivy2014

Joined: 2015-02-17

Posts: 588

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

this rule should finally come in effect as mafia 22 has officialy Dyed

RailMat

Formerly MatthijsFidder

From: Emmen (NL)

Joined: 2017-05-22

Posts: 1,534

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

I shouldn't add this rule.

I've also a mafia setup in mind.
It shall be a semi-open setup.

---

thanks AnatolyEE, lrussell, AnatolyEE, HG.

Anatoly

Guest

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

I've got also a plan on a very cool and amazing mafia 23, let me handle it. You'll not regret it!

Luka504

Member

From: Serbia,probs never heard of it

Joined: 2015-02-19

Posts: 2,934

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

I've got also a plan on a very cool and amazing mafia 23, let me handle it. You'll not regret it!

No.
Just.
No.
Hosting a mafia game is harder than it looks, Anatoly, and it's easy for the host to slip up and ruin the game for everyone. I don't trust you to not **** it up.

---

How long will it take me to get banned again?
Place your bets right here.

Kira

Member

Joined: 2019-04-22

Posts: 1,346

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

I've got also a plan on a very cool and amazing mafia 23, let me handle it. You'll not regret it!

That rule was made for you btw

GreenyMix

Formerly Snivy2014

Joined: 2015-02-17

Posts: 588

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

how about the submit button hosts mafia 23
they'd make a great host

RailMat

Formerly MatthijsFidder

From: Emmen (NL)

Joined: 2017-05-22

Posts: 1,534

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

I've got also a plan on a very cool and amazing mafia 23, let me handle it. You'll not regret it!

No.
Just.
No.
Hosting a mafia game is harder than it looks, Anatoly, and it's easy for the host to slip up and ruin the game for everyone. I don't trust you to not **** it up.

I know it is hard. But it can be fun. I'd made mistakes when I host a game. You must know how the game works. First play it servial times, and then can you be the host.

---

thanks AnatolyEE, lrussell, AnatolyEE, HG.

mrjawapa

Corn Man 🌽

From: Ohio, USA

Joined: 2015-02-15

Posts: 5,840

Website

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

I've got also a plan on a very cool and amazing mafia 23, let me handle it. You'll not regret it!

No. You're not allowed to host.

---

Discord: jawp#5123

RailMat

Formerly MatthijsFidder

From: Emmen (NL)

Joined: 2017-05-22

Posts: 1,534

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

I've got also a plan on a very cool and amazing mafia 23, let me handle it. You'll not regret it!

No. You're not allowed to host.

Try to not make people angry. Please give him a chance. If you don't like the host, plz don't join.

EDIT: what is your opinion of I host a mafia game.

---

thanks AnatolyEE, lrussell, AnatolyEE, HG.

TaskManager

Formerly maxi123

From: i really should update this

Joined: 2015-03-01

Posts: 9,465

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

Please give him a chance. If you don't like the host, plz don't join.

No because people will start hosting multiple mafia games and the players will split between these games and it's a ****

EDIT: what is your opinion of I host a mafia game.

I don't remember, have you ever played one on the forums..?

---

signature by HG, profile picture by bluecloud, thank!!
previous signature by drstereos

RailMat

Formerly MatthijsFidder

From: Emmen (NL)

Joined: 2017-05-22

Posts: 1,534

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

EDIT: what is your opinion of I host a mafia game.

I don't remember, have you ever played one on the forums..?

I've played 2 mafia games.

---

thanks AnatolyEE, lrussell, AnatolyEE, HG.

Anatoly

Guest

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

I've got also a plan on a very cool and amazing mafia 23, let me handle it. You'll not regret it!

No.
Just.
No.
Hosting a mafia game is harder than it looks, Anatoly, and it's easy for the host to slip up and ruin the game for everyone. I don't trust you to not **** it up.

Everyone should have a chance.

Onjit

Member

Joined: 2015-02-15

Posts: 9,709

Website

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

Here's a few criteria that i think you should meet before considering hosting a game

1. Availability - you have to be able to be online every day to actually put in the time to make sure the game is running smoothly
2. Writing skills - you have no not only have everything be understandable, but also have everything very clear with as little questions as possible
3. Neutrality - you must remain neutral at all times, regardless of what you would like to happen, this means that you cannot give responses to questions that give information away
4. Tact - you need to know when to answer a question, and when to let players figure it out for themselves

and thats before i even mention anything about mafia specifically

5. Game Balance - you need to understand that the best games of mafia are where the informed minority and uninformed majority both have the ability to win, and win fairly
6. Restraint - you must be able to know when less is more, and when not to make the game chaotic to the point where it is no longer fun to play

i'm sure i'm missing many other important aspects, but those are the ones i could think of off the top of my head

--------

so yeah, while i think that everyone should be able to host a game here, (there's no real order or anything), if you want people to actually join or play your game, you need to give people confidence that you can do it. Having more than two games (one where you were disqualified) might give people more confidence in your ability

---

:.|:;

Anatoly

Guest

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

onjit you failed with criteria 1!

Raphe9000

Member

Joined: 2015-03-16

Posts: 1,864

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

1. Availability - you have to be able to be online every day to actually put in the time to make sure the game is running smoothly

onjit you failed with criteria 1!

But Onjit understands that availability is a criterion and likely works to be available, so it's not really a failure as long as that doesn't happen too often. You also don't need to be good at something to know the qualities those who are good possess anyway.

Luka504

Member

From: Serbia,probs never heard of it

Joined: 2015-02-19

Posts: 2,934

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

Everyone should have a chance.

No, not everyone should. Some people just can't handle the responsibility of hosting a mafia game, and shouldn't host any games because of that. People should only host if they have a good reputation in the community.
Considering the number of controversies you've incited over the years, people have every right to believe you wouldn't take this responsibility... well, responsibly.

Besides, even if you open a sign-up topic, you likely won't get many people to take part, regardless of how good your idea may be. Fix your standing within the community first, then consider starting something like this.

---

How long will it take me to get banned again?
Place your bets right here.

Anatoly

Guest

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

Everyone should have a chance.

No, not everyone should. Some people just can't handle the responsibility of hosting a mafia game, and shouldn't host any games because of that. People should only host if they have a good reputation in the community.
Considering the number of controversies you've incited over the years, people have every right to believe you wouldn't take this responsibility... well, responsibly.

Besides, even if you open a sign-up topic, you likely won't get many people to take part, regardless of how good your idea may be. Fix your standing within the community first, then consider starting something like this.

Okay then YOU shouldn’t have a try.

I believe everyone should have a chance, and if I start my mafia, then simply don’t join.

And standing in the community won’t change if 50% of your posts are “Anatoly, shut up”

Luka504

Member

From: Serbia,probs never heard of it

Joined: 2015-02-19

Posts: 2,934

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

Yes, I agree. I've raised problems in the past myself, and people have every right to assume that I'd do a **** job of hosting a mafia game.
But, unlike you, I don't keep trying to convince people they should give me a chance. If I have to persuade someone to trust me, they obviously don't trust me.

So I'd recommend growing some self-awareness, and stop pursuing this.

---

How long will it take me to get banned again?
Place your bets right here.

TaskManager

Formerly maxi123

From: i really should update this

Joined: 2015-03-01

Posts: 9,465

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

And standing in the community won’t change if 50% of your posts are “Anatoly, shut up”

hmm i wonder why

---

signature by HG, profile picture by bluecloud, thank!!
previous signature by drstereos

Kira

Member

Joined: 2019-04-22

Posts: 1,346

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

Not only you have 19.99 iq but you want to host a game, you have exceeded all my expectations I’ll give you that

Onjit

Member

Joined: 2015-02-15

Posts: 9,709

Website

Re: Mafia 23 discussion

onjit you failed with criteria 1!

How so? I make the time constraints very clear when I say that I won't be online for the final hammer, and I make it clear what players should do after that happens. Quite frankly it is you who can't seem to comprehend the idea of availability, as you seem unable to be patient and wait a few hours.

Mafia in this forum format is intentionally slow - there's a reason each day phase can take up to 72 hours.

---

:.|:;