Mafia 16 [TIE]

mutantdevle · 2017-10-18 17:44:14

Also this is just a quick scum read, I know there's not much to go on at the moment but these are just my initial thoughts.

Zumza - Slightly scummy, derp more than anything.
HeyNK - Slightly scummy.
Emalton - Can't tell.
Slabdrill - Can't tell.
MartenM - Just seems clueless.
AnatolyEE - Slightly scummy.
jkdrip - Town.
Onjit - Derp town.
N1KF - Yet to comment.
hummerz5 - Derp town.

Devlin - Werewolves and devils are basically the same thing right?

MatthijsFidder - Orange you glad he isn't still using blue?

RailMat · 2017-10-18 17:50:46

Devlin wrote:

MatthijsFidder - Orange you glad he isn't still using blue?

because MartenM tells me it is harder to read on a dark background. that is why I use orange

N1KF if you don't post before Night 1 you'll be prodded

RailMat · 2017-10-18 20:59:03

19 hours left.

6 votes needed for majority

HeyNK · 2017-10-19 00:04:49

WTF 19 HOURS LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL

Yeah lynch me day 1, just keep in mind that scum was on my wagon.

ahaahaaha day 1 is over as soon as it started im done playing this game hahahaahah

HeyNK · 2017-10-19 00:05:30

HARDCLAIM VT, PEACE OUT BADBOYS

mutantdevle · 2017-10-19 00:08:17

HeyNK aren’t you supposed to be an experienced Mafia player? Because your irrational behaviour definitely doesn’t give that impression.

Onjit

Onjit · 2017-10-19 00:14:20

Devlin wrote:

HeyNK aren’t you supposed to be an experienced Mafia player? Because your irrational behaviour definitely doesn’t give that impression.

He's experienced at getting lynched D1

Slabdrill, Harmonious, Zumza, hummerz5, mutantdevle

HeyNK · 2017-10-19 00:50:31

I've been lynched d1 as town in a game with 2 week days. This is a a funhouse blitz game! Partyyyy!

(reminder for those town that are trying to win: there is no motivation for me as scum to be posting this much trash when I am well aware lurking to victory wins scum games on this forum~!)

RailMat · 2017-10-19 05:12:15

Lees than 11 hours left

6 votes needed for majority

mutantdevle · 2017-10-19 07:28:11

Yo @everyone, start voting.

I’m going to be especially critical of people who fail to vote as I consider not doing that a scum action. You don’t have to be certain on your vote, just vote for someone.

N1KF · 2017-10-19 07:48:38

Devlin wrote:

Yo @everyone, start voting.

k

I forgot this game and I need to go so see you folks Day 2 but here's the unpolished analysis I have:

▼Day 1 analysis

Zumza quickly votes for nolynch. Intriguing. Contrasts Devlin. Devlin doesn't want nolynch. Nolynching could help the werewolves, which seems to suggest that Devlin's supporting the town. But this is a basic Day 1 debate that gets brought up each day and Devlin is a smart guy so this likely doesn't mean anything.

Emalton admits he is resistant to vote. Nervous town? Nervous werewolves? I don't know, but I get town vibes.

MaternM and Devlin woot Zumza's post. Here's an question to ponder: do any of the three have some sort of relation? *detective music plays*

Slabdrill clumsily admits vanilla townie. Gives me bad vibes. His "confirmation" is none other than the basic rules behind all vanilla townies in Mafia games. Or maybe he doesn't realize that and is just a bad player. Anatoly does the same thing later after his weird suicidal phase.

Devlin contrasts Zumza yet agian! More conflict. Time for a showdown? Not yet. But it's interesting to watch. Devlin is going all aggressive. But at the same time, he seems like an intellect willing to talk things out. A fiendish mastermind, perhaps? Or just a helpful townie?

Hummerz is making small comments and stuff. Nothing unusual here for the ol' hummeroo.

jkdrip is acting like Anatoly, but instead of being suicidal, he's omnicidal. Go figure.

HeyNK doesn't like hummerz. Go figure. He also has a good taste in avatars. Much better than mine at the moment. That aside, he does seem to be the blunt no-nonsense guy. But that's a double negative, so does that make him the blunt sense guy?

jkdrip says Hey to the HeyNK and calls him out. HeyNK seems rather defensive. HeyNK looks kinda suspicious... Devlin seems vaguely neutral towards this. ARE THEY BOTH WEREWOLVES, ALONG WITH MARTENM AND ZUMZA? Probably not, actually. That would be really unlikely.

Onjit is beautifully brief towards HeyNK. Starts a bandwagon of votes, but werewolves usually hide in the middle of a bandwagon. He just looks like a silly townie to me.

jkdrip votes against HeyNK right after Onjit does. Even after Devlin responds against him, he is still against for HeyNK, with actually good reasons. jkdrip gives me town vibes.

Anatoly is being nooby. Claiming vanilla townie raises an eyebrow but that's a noob mistake I made so I'll give him a pass. I think he's either a vanilla townie or a werewolf. He also wants to be lynched because he doesn't want to play? Ok then.

Devlin is #3 on the HeyNK bandwagon. Common scum sign.

HeyNK is really hamming it up. A bit crazy but HeyNK is usually crazy. Still doesn't excuse it though.

Devlin and Onjit agree with each other...again. Okay, Onjit's scumminess went up slightly but still less scummy than Devlin.

SCALE O' SCUMMINESS

Devlin
HeyNK
Slabdrill
AnatolyEE
Onjit
hummerz5
MartenM
Emalton
Zumza
jkdrip

Something I didn't address earlier were the lurkers. Lurkers, particularly Emalton and Slabdrill went up the list a bit because they didn't speak much. Lurkers aren't very helpful, plus, it's a common sign that a they're trying to hide something. Or they just forget about the game, like I did earlier.

!vote Devlin

I would vote for HeyNK but I think he'll make the lynch. So here's a hipster vote for you all.

mutantdevle · 2017-10-19 08:03:51

hE sEeMs InTeLlIgEnT mUsT bE sCuM!!!

So basically according to you N1KF this is my list of crimes:

- Helpfulness doesn’t count because I’m allegedly intelligent (thanks for the compliment?)
- I woot posts
- I didn’t blindly follow the HeyNK wagon
- I was the 3rd to vote on the wagon
- I agree with Onjit

Also just saying but if you’re going to criticise lurking then maybe you should post more first?

N1KF · 2017-10-19 08:15:52

Devlin wrote:

Also just saying but if you’re going to criticise lurking then maybe you should post more first?

The difference between me and the lurkers is that I've actually helped the game out a lot by posting a truckload of my raw thoughts. Meanwhile they've done pretty much nothing, but maybe they'll make a great comeback like I did. If so I'll be more forgiving of them Day 2.

I REALLY need to go so I don't have time to think about the other things you said, but I'll keep that in mind Day 2. (And maybe Night 1 if I have night actions. )

The following was written before I clicked preview and saw your post:

Actually, you know what? I wouldn't sleep well at night knowing that my hipster vote caused Devlin to get lynched, and I seriously doubt Devlin will get five more votes in the next eight hours. So here's a normie vote for you all.
Though, personally, I don't think I'd sleep well at night either way, considering the risk of werewolves killing me or townsfolk.
!vote HeyNK
I'll consider Devlin a vote for Day 2, but Slabdrill and Anatoly are also big ones if they don't speak up about the actual game.

N1KF · 2017-10-19 08:17:23

To clarify, I still vote for HeyNK. In hindsight that wasn't completely clear.

Harmonious · 2017-10-19 11:51:49

Emalton, Marten, Anatoly, Slabdrill, and humz can all vote. I think Zumza is still banned so he's excused. Speaking of which, anyone know how long Zumza is banned for?

Zumza · 2017-10-19 11:54:03

Hi whatzzaap up?! !vote devlin

Meanwhile some other observations:

Devlin wrote:

jkdrip wrote:
Also to clarify I only support d1 NoLynch.
Why? There are so many benefits to lynching each and every day, including day 1. Assuming the mafia kills every night, a no lynch gives an even number of players making it harder to reach a majority. Also, the less total players in the game, the more likely our lynch will be a scum.

No, theres actually a very good rule of lynching that statistically plays off very well: keeping an odd number of players alive every day. The main reason is for keeping a better town decision.

jkdrip wrote:

The reason I support d1 NoLynch is because if we're going to random lynch, scum will influence the votes in such a way that it lands on town. After d1, since PRs might OPT to be quiet instead of having nothing to say, I'm more comfortable lynching.
You're right about Onjit, but HeyNK is acting cocky which is annoying

A vote is very important, as previously mentioned, it can indicate the views of people. Even if we lynch a townie we could take the vote list as a reliable source to form a list of subjects.

mutantdevle · 2017-10-19 11:58:23

Apparently, Zumza is banned for -1 hours.

Also just saying, we have 4 hours left. If you don't want a no-lynch then you should probably be voting HeyNK who is currently L-2. By all means, build a case against me tomorrow (on what basis I am really confused to know?) but for now, for the sake of the town, we need to get a lynch in.

Zumza wrote:

No, theres actually a very good rule of lynching that statistically plays off very well: keeping an odd number of players alive every day.

That is exactly what I am saying... If we don't lynch and mafia kills then there will be an even number of players which will put us at a disadvantage.

Zumza · 2017-10-19 12:16:11

Sadly I thought we have more time than this. !unvote Devlin wasn't really a true vote, just wanted to see the feedback.

Getting back:

My vote counts as much as everybody else's, I can't do something in which I don't believe.. I don't agree with voting HeyNK for two reasons:
1. I don't believe his scum
2. If he truly is what he says there have 2 be two kills tonight. He has to prove himself or he'll truly loose town's trust.

However if others decide he must be lynched, I will not oppose.

mutantdevle

hummerz5 · 2017-10-19 13:58:13

honestly I'm not feeling one way or the other on this. I could vote HeyNK but zumza has a slight point in favor of leaving him around. If the vigilante claim is false then all the real vig has to do is not kill while we expect heynk to actually kill. Assuming the mafia doesn't have a roleblocker we could clear him in the night. Unless he dies I guess.

but I don't see us wagoning on anyone else with such short notice...

Harmonious · 2017-10-19 13:58:18

What's your take on all this, Emalton?

Idk why multiple people consider me town, moreso than others, but hey! I'll take it

mutantdevle · 2017-10-19 14:04:42

When did HeyNK day he was a vig?

He says he hard claims VT. That’s vanilla townie is it not?

hummerz5 · 2017-10-19 14:14:45

oh my misunderstanding

!vote henynk

mutantdevle · 2017-10-19 14:35:45

In B4 HeyNK now claims a power role because that would have saved him.

Also with the whole vig thing, we know that role isn’t in the game because matt told us the role names in the signup thread.

hummerz5

mutantdevle · 2017-10-19 14:40:20

Oh also HeyNK is at L1 if I’m not mistaken.

John · 2017-10-19 14:50:18

!vote heynk

Official Everybody Edits Forums

#51 2017-10-18 17:44:14

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#52 2017-10-18 17:50:46

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#53 2017-10-18 20:59:03

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#54 2017-10-19 00:04:49

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#55 2017-10-19 00:05:30

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#56 2017-10-19 00:08:17

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#57 2017-10-19 00:14:20

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#58 2017-10-19 00:50:31

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#59 2017-10-19 05:12:15, last edited by RailMat (2017-10-19 05:12:55)

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#60 2017-10-19 07:28:11

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#61 2017-10-19 07:48:38

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

SCALE O' SCUMMINESS

#62 2017-10-19 08:03:51

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#63 2017-10-19 08:15:52

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#64 2017-10-19 08:17:23

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#65 2017-10-19 11:51:49

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#66 2017-10-19 11:54:03

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#67 2017-10-19 11:58:23

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#68 2017-10-19 12:16:11

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#69 2017-10-19 13:58:13

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#70 2017-10-19 13:58:18

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#71 2017-10-19 14:04:42

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#72 2017-10-19 14:14:45

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#73 2017-10-19 14:35:45

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#74 2017-10-19 14:40:20

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

#75 2017-10-19 14:50:18

Re: Mafia 16 [TIE]

Board footer