EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

Luka504 · 2016-06-23 00:40:26

Creature wrote:

maxi123 wrote:
Creature wrote:
Also, you can't just go to a case and act like "oh you should explain better", this is what makes scum hunting way harder. Scum are going to ask for explanation so they can answer with something made up and then say "oh i answered everything"
well if town follows bandwagons mindlessly it makes it easy for mafia to push a mislynch no?
You don't have to automatically follow me, but you just can't go to any case and say "there's no explanation so i am not voting" unless you're townreading the accusee. If you're really town and not lazy, you would check that user and actually analyse yourself before deciding whether to vote.

HEY!
LETS LYNCH CREATURE!
WHY!?
DONT ASK JUST DO IT.
!vote Creatyre

Creature · 2016-06-23 00:41:08

"The best defense you can do is being town yourself, answering questions can be easily faked, but genuine scum hunting can't." ~Mafia Theory.

Creature · 2016-06-23 00:42:10

At least I can brag postgame that I was actually going for scum.

Different55 · 2016-06-23 00:42:14

hummerz5 wrote:

Different55 wrote:
Creature wrote:
Also, you can't just go to a case and act like "oh you should explain better", this is what makes scum hunting way harder. Scum are going to ask for explanation so they can answer with something made up and then say "oh i answered everything"
... You mean like you've been doing with every question thrown at you the whole game?
It's interesting the number of times you've brought that up and seemingly the number of times we've ignored them (Not just Creature, I mean) Perhaps we should place a little more emphasis on this.

This is also why I repeat so often the "maybe not guilty doesn't mean not scum", because every bit of me is screaming that Creature is up to something. Yesterday for a brief amount of time I thought it was because he was protecting the doctor and himself from being targetted by mafia but the doctor's been outed and the person he was so dead set on killing turns out to not look like a huge glowing scum beacon. If he were an investigator he would have said so by now, so what's he still hiding?

Evilbunny · 2016-06-23 00:43:42

Even a blind squirrel finds a nut every once in awhile.

If you point enough fingers at a bunch of different players then you are gonna eventually accuse a mafia.

Creature · 2016-06-23 00:44:24

Different55
Yes, I have an investigation ability, it's called scumhunting and townhunting.

Creature · 2016-06-23 00:51:20

Everyone
Say "not guilty" actually means confirmed town and all inactives are town, who's scum?

Unau · 2016-06-23 00:54:18

yes

Unau · 2016-06-23 00:54:39

no but actually i can talk to dead people so im good to keep around

Unau · 2016-06-23 00:55:22

i have my ways

Luka504 · 2016-06-23 00:57:03

Creature wrote:

Everyone
Say "not guilty" actually means confirmed town and all inactives are town, who's scum?

Ok no funposting, no joke but i have to ask.
What are you even trying to do?
You keep saying some chinese quotes to make you seem like you are trying to find mafia.
Then you keep saying: Lynch this guy,
No lynch that guy.
Town:,,Why?,,

THERES NO EXPLANATION NEEDED JUST DO IT.
You never even explained why you think im mafia or why hummerz is mafia, you just keep pointing the finger and hope the town blindly follows.

If you want to save what little credibility you have, give some actual reasons to why someone is suspicious. And make sure to not make up 10 lies when they arent needed.

Different55 · 2016-06-23 00:59:11

Unau wrote:

i have my ways

There's a graveyard chat, why would you be able to speak with the dead when the dead can speak with each other and possibly reveal information that couldn't have been obtained while playing the game? In every graveyard chat I've ever been in there have been heavy spoilers, except for the Undertale game, which only had a spectator chat for the same reason, dead players would have gotten spoiled in there..

Unau · 2016-06-23 01:05:37

Different55 wrote:

Unau wrote:
i have my ways
There's a graveyard chat, why would you be able to speak with the dead when the dead can speak with each other and possibly reveal information that couldn't have been obtained while playing the game? In every graveyard chat I've ever been in there have been heavy spoilers, except for the Undertale game, which only had a spectator chat for the same reason, dead players would have gotten spoiled in there..

i can read the chat tho
marco gave me the link because it's my power

Creature · 2016-06-23 01:06:40

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Different55 wrote:
Everybody role claim D1 then we find out who is mafia because they'll have crappy made up roles.
Although this is a marco game so instead we could identify mafia by the roles that don't sound crappy and a made up. srry marco bby ily <3
I can tell you right now. This would get Town nowhere and be really helpful for scum. You have to realize two things. Scum can claim just about anything, and in games like these the moderator usually provides fake claims for Mafia. We wouldn't find any scum but we would tell the Mafia who to attack first.

Fluff

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Different55 wrote:
RhazzleFrazzle wrote:
provides fake claims for Mafia.
why
do they hate us
So Town can't cheese their way to a win and solve the game D1.

Fluff

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Nolynching gets Town nowhere and refusing to lynch without evidence is why Town lost game 5. Lynching Kuba is our best bet because we have no other good targets and we would actually get something out of it even if he's Town.
!vote Kuba
Bimps and Diff should be watched if Kuba flips Town. I feel like they might be pushing on the weakest link.

More fluff, poor reason to lynch Kuba.

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Kuba is damn near close to confirmed Town in my eyes. I don't see him as someone that would make that kind of claim D1 as scum. Probably Town who just claimed before he should have. Anyways with 15 players who all have a PR at least one of us has the ability to keep Kuba alive tonight, so protect him (Or me ).

Setup specing, no actual scum hunting.

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Not wanting to lynch without hard evidence isn't a scum tell. It's an idiot tell.

Fluff.

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Like I said. With 15 players and no Citizen like roles there's gonna be at least one person that can stop a Mafia kill. I'm not sure if Marco notifies people if they were hit by an unsuccessful attack though.

Fluff.

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

You realize that you just hardclaimed scum with Town majority right? Plus I'm not sure what marco is doing with your role, but usually that role has to be alive at the end of the game to win.

More fluff.

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Creature wrote:
Non-town = Scum
^^^

Fluff and possibly buddying.

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Unau isn't a bad check. Now Mafia can't push for a policy lynch on him. Still not the best though. I think we've already decided on lynching Diff today honestly, because there aren't any better targets popping up.

Aiming for towncred.

Creature · 2016-06-23 01:07:35

Luka504 wrote:

Creature wrote:
Everyone
Say "not guilty" actually means confirmed town and all inactives are town, who's scum?
Ok no funposting, no joke but i have to ask.
What are you even trying to do?
You keep saying some chinese quotes to make you seem like you are trying to find mafia.
Then you keep saying: Lynch this guy,
No lynch that guy.
Town:,,Why?,,
THERES NO EXPLANATION NEEDED JUST DO IT.
You never even explained why you think im mafia or why hummerz is mafia, you just keep pointing the finger and hope the town blindly follows.
If you want to save what little credibility you have, give some actual reasons to why someone is suspicious. And make sure to not make up 10 lies when they arent needed.

Are you trying to find scum? If yes, then answer the question I quoted.

Creature · 2016-06-23 01:14:37

Most of his posts look like fluffing, his scumreads are bad, he avoids scumhunting to sheep wagons already in formation, he attacks Different55 with generic info and then disappears. This is very different from his towngame where he's more aggressive and has his own opinions.

!vote RhazzleFrazzle

TaskManager · 2016-06-23 01:47:28

i dont agree with all of creature's "fluff" accusations but i had the gut feeling towards rhaz since d1
and tbh this makes sense:

Creature wrote:

his is very different from his towngame where he's more aggressive and has his own opinions.

i can see major difference between rhaz's play this time and his usual play where he rushes to get "town leader" spot and is going agressive on everyone

!vote RhazzleFrazzle

meanwhile n1kf should be prodded for inactivity or else ill hang his **** on a rope

Different55 · 2016-06-23 02:09:12

Creature wrote:

he attacks Different55 with generic info and then disappears

Then please tell me what the everloving crap you were doing all day yesterday, and with Luka all D1

Onjit

Different55 · 2016-06-23 02:10:29

Different55 wrote:

Creature wrote:
he attacks Different55 with generic info and then disappears
Then please tell me what the everloving crap you were doing all day yesterday, and with Luka all D1

without the vanishing tho

also you did come back D2 with more genericness for luka, I forgot about that for a second

Onjit

Different55 · 2016-06-23 02:10:45

Unau wrote:

Different55 wrote:
Unau wrote:
i have my ways
There's a graveyard chat, why would you be able to speak with the dead when the dead can speak with each other and possibly reveal information that couldn't have been obtained while playing the game? In every graveyard chat I've ever been in there have been heavy spoilers, except for the Undertale game, which only had a spectator chat for the same reason, dead players would have gotten spoiled in there..
i can read the chat tho
marco gave me the link because it's my power

consider me jelly

Creature · 2016-06-23 02:14:49

I really wished I was a vig.

Creature · 2016-06-23 02:15:33

If I were a vig:
- 3 scum would be dead in total.
- There wouldn't have these **** arguments.

Creature · 2016-06-23 02:16:51

The difference, Diff, is that I actually had a reason to scumread Luka504.

Different55 · 2016-06-23 02:22:50

Does anyone else think that Creature is trying to hint at us that he's mafia because like twice today he's accused others of doing something that he's been doing basically the whole game.

Creature wrote:

he attacks [users] with generic info

^Dude threw like 500 generic-sounding lies at Luka D1, D2 he said that he did all that lying for the incredibly powerful reason that "his mind felt different".

Different55 wrote:

Creature wrote:
Also, you can't just go to a case and act like "oh you should explain better", this is what makes scum hunting way harder. Scum are going to ask for explanation so they can answer with something made up and then say "oh i answered everything"
... You mean like you've been doing with every question thrown at you the whole game?

^Dude's been dodging questions like he's in the matrix, and when we finally squeezed one out of him yesterday it was that same retardedly generic "his mind felt different". Like no you don't spew lies like that just because you have a bad feeling.

Also this

If I were a vig:
- 3 scum would be dead in total.
- There wouldn't have these **** arguments.

Really? Because you haven't found a single mafia yet. You honestly think you could have won this game by now? Get stuffed.

Onjit, hummerz5

Different55 · 2016-06-23 02:24:21

Creature wrote:

The difference, Diff, is that I actually had a reason to scumread Luka504.

And that reason was "his mind felt different". What a strong reason that was.

You still have never actually said "X is mafia" yet. You've said just about every generic-sounding thing you could, but never that. If you're an investigator, you should have either found a bunch of townies or a bunch of mafia or some combination of both. You've already roleclaimed investigator so why not spill everything you know already?

Onjit

Official Everybody Edits Forums

#526 2016-06-23 00:40:26

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#527 2016-06-23 00:41:08

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#528 2016-06-23 00:42:10

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#529 2016-06-23 00:42:14

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#530 2016-06-23 00:43:42

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#531 2016-06-23 00:44:24

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#532 2016-06-23 00:51:20

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#533 2016-06-23 00:54:18

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#534 2016-06-23 00:54:39

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#535 2016-06-23 00:55:22

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#536 2016-06-23 00:57:03

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#537 2016-06-23 00:59:11

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#538 2016-06-23 01:05:37

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#539 2016-06-23 01:06:40

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#540 2016-06-23 01:07:35

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#541 2016-06-23 01:14:37

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#542 2016-06-23 01:47:28

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#543 2016-06-23 02:09:12

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#544 2016-06-23 02:10:29

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#545 2016-06-23 02:10:45

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#546 2016-06-23 02:14:49

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#547 2016-06-23 02:15:33

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#548 2016-06-23 02:16:51

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#549 2016-06-23 02:22:50

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#550 2016-06-23 02:24:21

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

Board footer