EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

Different55 · 2016-06-19 21:25:50

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

So Diff. Why should we let you live when you're just pushing on a near confirmed Townie? Doesn't sound like helping the Town to me.

Remember earlier in the day when I was reminded that he was confirmed townie, I said I was conflicted? Everything was pointing towards "creature is trying something" but Kuba said he was not guilty. EB and who was it, hummerz? They thought maybe "Not guilty" doesn't mean "town", it just means "not guilty", in which case that'd make sense. Nobody died last night, there's nothing to be guilty of. Really I don't think marco would have used the phrasing "not guilty" if he really meant "town". It just wouldn't come to you naturally unless it fit what was going on behind the scenes more. Idk, maybe marco can clarify what he meant by not guilty but until then I'm assuming the "not guilty" = "not guilty of killing anyone" because Creature has constantly lied, lied about lying, and has dodged every question on his reasoning. Honestly the fact that you're so sure that "not guilty" = "town" is kind of suspicious by itself. But if I were mafia and one of my members had gotten a "not guilty", you can bet your booty I'd be holding on to that as hard as I could.

hummerz5

Creature · 2016-06-19 21:26:59

It's a daycop, Kuba got his result before the night.

Creature · 2016-06-19 21:27:48

Also, if the guilty worked like this, Kuba would be notified, otherwise this is bastard.

TaskManager · 2016-06-19 21:29:11

Different55 wrote:

I'm suspicious of him, only because Creature is mindlessly and practically wordlessly defending him.

just gonna say that idk why you suspect me for someone else's actions
also, creature didnt defend me but rather told rhaz to change his target?

Zumza · 2016-06-19 21:42:39

Different55 wrote:

Zumza can you tell us more about your PM?

Marco told me that at night I heard the door beat. Before realising(I'm a bit of heavy sleeper sry) I was shoot. After some bleeding a smiley of mine town cured me. The rest is just blah blah.
Considering that Rhazzle claimed to be a vigilant on D1 and probably he felt provoked when I ask him if he expects to be murdered soon, I think he decided to try his bullet on me. I'm sad Marco didn't told me earlier about this because I would have go to the lottery.

Creature · 2016-06-19 21:42:57

This must be why Different55's goal is to trick everyone.

Creature · 2016-06-19 21:43:29

lmao night feedback is so funny.

Different55 · 2016-06-19 21:44:08

maxi123 wrote:

Different55 wrote:
I'm suspicious of him, only because Creature is mindlessly and practically wordlessly defending him.
just gonna say that idk why you suspect me for someone else's actions
also, creature didnt defend me but rather told rhaz to change his target?

Sorry man. Just by yourself I don't really find you that suspicious, but I find it suspicious that Creature's protecting you so hard but refuses to say why.
But it wasn't just the thing with rhaz, he also said at the start of the day when he voted for me: "We are not nolynching today, and we are not lynching maxi." or something to that effect.

Creature wrote:

It's a daycop, Kuba got his result before the night.

Hey, sorry, hi. I must be missing something, I don't see what that has to do with what I said.

Creature wrote:

Also, if the guilty worked like this, Kuba would be notified, otherwise this is bastard.

Not really. Last game role investigative roles were a lot worse. We weren't notified until afterwards. Give marco a chance to clear it up before saying "No that's nonsense, obviously that's not how it works so obviously I'm town."

And for the love of all that is holy explain yourself.

hummerz5 · 2016-06-19 22:19:11

Creature wrote:

It's a daycop, Kuba got his result before the night.

Indeed. Glad you remembered my "guilty" ambiguity brainchild. Yes, as creature points out, the "not guilty" would show up on just about everyone, as no N1 activities could have taken place yet.

@Diff: Yeah, I wondered where that "not lynching maxi either" came from. Oh. And you have a secret plan. Good luck; it seems likely you'll get free reign. Yes, Creature is a suspicious gent. I'd venture that he's in a position not altogether unlike your own: considerable power, aligned with either group, super secret plan. Emphasis on the plan part; clearly he's dragging the other one. At the same time, the other school of thought that your endgame isn't determined... and that you have to trick everyone... makes your actions suspect. Atm you certainly appear to be an asset...
!unvote

@Maxi: Yeah well it's guilt by perceived association. I guess you might not have anything to do with it, but the accusatory word seems to have more weight than not.

Creature · 2016-06-19 22:21:35

Oh nice, I guess my role is a lie too.

Creature · 2016-06-19 22:22:07

!dayvig Luka504

Let's see if I have a secret ability too.

Luka504 · 2016-06-19 22:26:02

Creature wrote:

!dayvig Luka504
Let's see if I have a secret ability too.

Ugh....
What?

TaskManager · 2016-06-19 22:29:59

Creature wrote:

!dayvig Luka504

what

Different55 wrote:

But it wasn't just the thing with rhaz, he also said at the start of the day when he voted for me: "We are not nolynching today, and we are not lynching maxi." or something to that effect.

uh idk about that
could be like game 5 (or 6, i dont remember) where luka protected me and then flipped mafia, which suggested that i would be mafia too (yet i was town)

Different55 · 2016-06-19 22:58:13

Dang it. Seriously, this blows. Creature, assuming you're not totally full of crap, do you have to be so stubborn and suspicious about everything? Why did you start coming after me instead of continuing to push luka if you knew he was mafia?

Luka could you please tell us more about your role beyond it being "protective"? What kind of protection do you offer? Protection from death? Do you block people from having a role used on them?

hummerz5 wrote:

your endgame isn't determined... and that you have to trick everyone... makes your actions suspect.

Turns out the "tricking everyone" bit is just flavor anyway.

This would be so much easier if we could confirm what "not guilty" really meant but until we get that verified I'm either going to really regret this or really really not regret this but screw it here goes nothing.
!unvote
!vote Luka

Different55 · 2016-06-20 01:34:39

Guys make sure you use your last words as best as you can. Like if you have any info, make sure to squeeze it all in there BEFORE you die.

Also please vote Luka thank you.

Evilbunny · 2016-06-20 03:07:48

Zumza wrote:

I was shoot. After some bleeding a smiley of mine town cured me.

Ok I'm going to assume the mafia went after you Zumza. It might have been a vig, but I don't think you looked scummy enough D1 to warrant a Vig choosing you. Kinda weird pick for a doctor too but ok, gj Doc.

The only person you accused D1 was Luka here.
This^ combined with all the other stuff Diff and others have said makes Luka seem pretty scummy, or at least our best lynch.

!vote Luka

Also Creature I don't know what you are doing but don't act like anybody thinks you are a confirmed town, because we don't.

Zumza

Unau · 2016-06-20 03:21:48

may, not only can i read, but i can also type as my pr

Kirby · 2016-06-20 03:24:28

Kaleb123 wrote:

Also this is needed ...
!Vote Kirby

"OMGUS!!!!!"

hummerz5 · 2016-06-20 03:31:40

OK let's address something
Am I the only person who thinks that we're losing function by everyone splitting off to pursue their own "OMG YOU" moments? Or is that a regular thing with mafia games?

I feel like we'd be better off having some certainty that our lurkers are paying attention and that we each, with our tangents, are considering others' words not just for the offensive.

Am I simply being pessimistic like evilbunny? (:P) Should I hold my horses, D1 hasn't even been half over?
Btw, I checked and everyone has posted in after N1, so my idea that someone might not have checked yet is invalidated.

Kirby · 2016-06-20 03:36:41

Oh, by the way, i mentioned this earlier but i can try to kill someone every night. be careful though, bc if you investigate me you get killed (i think?).

I, uh, may have tried to get rid of kaleb, but it didnt work. he must have some sort of protection towards it.

!vote luka

after isolating, it just hurts to look at

Evilbunny · 2016-06-20 03:39:38

Kirby wrote:

Oh, by the way, i mentioned this earlier but i can try to kill someone every night. be careful though, bc if you investigate me you get killed (i think?).

Did you just claim Serial Killer?
GDI, if we have another one I'm gonna scream.

Kirby · 2016-06-20 03:40:26

Evilbunny wrote:

Kirby wrote:
Oh, by the way, i mentioned this earlier but i can try to kill someone every night. be careful though, bc if you investigate me you get killed (i think?).
Did you just claim Serial Killer?
GDI, if we have another one I'm gonna scream.

no, im still a townie. I only have 3 kills*

Kirby · 2016-06-20 03:41:41

im a wiz and my magic trick went wrong so im just here in ee, using the code. 10/10 backstory marco

Different55 · 2016-06-20 05:02:39

Different55 wrote:

Luka could you please tell us more about your role beyond it being "protective"? What kind of protection do you offer? Protection from death? Do you block people from having a role used on them?

Repeating for visibility.

Unau wrote:

may, not only can i read, but i can also type as my pr

Okay but what does that mean

Kirby wrote:

I, uh, may have tried to get rid of kaleb

Why kaleb?

Kirby wrote:

but it didnt work. he must have some sort of protection towards it

That's kind of interesting. Kaleb what kind of messages did you get from your near death experience?

hummerz5 wrote:

OK let's address something
Am I the only person who thinks that we're losing function by everyone splitting off to pursue their own "OMG YOU" moments? Or is that a regular thing with mafia games?

tbh I think it's kind of ridiculous how fast everyone is switching from one bandwagon to the other. First me, then Creature, now Luka. I'd love to see more general discussion about everyone though instead of just the current lynchee.

For example, Rhaz. I went back and he seems like he's playing fairly town-y just looking at who he votes for, why, and when he unvotes. Speaking of rhaz,

Zumza wrote:

Considering that Rhazzle claimed to be a vigilant on D1

Where? I didn't see that anywhere.

RhazzleFrazzle · 2016-06-20 05:08:18

To clarify, I never claimed Vigilante. I claimed what I assumed was an obvious joke, but I never put a serious claim forward.

Different55

Official Everybody Edits Forums

#301 2016-06-19 21:25:50

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#302 2016-06-19 21:26:59

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#303 2016-06-19 21:27:48

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#304 2016-06-19 21:29:11

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#305 2016-06-19 21:42:39

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#306 2016-06-19 21:42:57

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#307 2016-06-19 21:43:29

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#308 2016-06-19 21:44:08

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#309 2016-06-19 22:19:11

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#310 2016-06-19 22:21:35

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#311 2016-06-19 22:22:07

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#312 2016-06-19 22:26:02

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#313 2016-06-19 22:29:59

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#314 2016-06-19 22:58:13

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#315 2016-06-20 01:34:39

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#316 2016-06-20 03:07:48

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#317 2016-06-20 03:21:48

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#318 2016-06-20 03:24:28

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#319 2016-06-20 03:31:40

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#320 2016-06-20 03:36:41

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#321 2016-06-20 03:39:38

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#322 2016-06-20 03:40:26

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#323 2016-06-20 03:41:41

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#324 2016-06-20 05:02:39

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#325 2016-06-20 05:08:18

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

Board footer