EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

Kirby · 2016-06-18 22:33:10

maxi123 wrote:

hummerz5 wrote:
Strictly speaking, you can still take a guess as to what happened with your role. Then we can look to see who would have controlled you based on that. Of course, there are flaws with that: your role would be exposed and how would we know how whomever controlled you knew what you'd do? Sounds like a coop deal. Or, they controlled an investigative role.
i asked marco through PM and he said that my night actions weren't spent
weird

neither were mine, but i didnt hear anything about being controlled

Different55 · 2016-06-18 22:36:54

Come up with a better idea and if I like it better I'll switch. I'm not stuck on Luka, I guess he's more like a default setting for me when nothing else comes up at this point. More than that I want Creature to explain why he's making up reasons to lynch him.

Luka504 wrote:

What is more benefical for mafia?
Lynching ~~a townie~~ me or not lynching at all?

FTFY
and do you really want me to answer that

Different55 · 2016-06-18 22:37:14

Also friendly reminder that that post was written yesterday.

Luka504 · 2016-06-18 22:39:39

Different55 wrote:

Come up with a better idea and if I like it better I'll switch. I'm not stuck on Luka, I guess he's more like a default setting for me when nothing else comes up at this point. More than that I want Creature to explain why he's making up reasons to lynch him.
It doesnt matter if Luka is town or nah, we will lynch him beacuse we have no leads
A plan that worked soooooo well last game.
Luka504 wrote:
What is more benefical for mafia?
Lynching ~~a townie~~ me or not lynching at all?
FTFY
and do you really want me to answer that
Yes i do want you to anwser the question, without editing it.
What is more benefical for mafia?
Lynching a townie or not lynching at all

kubapolish · 2016-06-18 22:46:50

list of lurkers/fluffposters imo:
Unau [until post #7]
kubapolish bimps kaleb123 Kirby [until post #6]

AlphaJon wrote:

Who did you investigate and what was your result?

on D1

Kubapolish wrote:

i checked creature and he is not guilty yay

http://forums.everybodyedits.com/viewto … 45#p607245

Different55 wrote:

Unau wrote:
maxi123 wrote:
i have been controlled this night. thats all i was told so dont ask me what does that means, i know as much as you do
i was too what
Maybe that's Kuba's target swap ability.

nope
i even tried to swap someone but i couldnt because i already used check ability yesterday :v

btw i have a choice to check someone now or swap targets tonight
what should i do

Luka504 · 2016-06-18 22:49:36

So if it wasnt Kuba.......
Yeahp. Witchas confirmed.

RhazzleFrazzle · 2016-06-18 23:01:31

Kuba if you can use your check go for Diff right now.

Luka504 · 2016-06-18 23:06:48

Lets wait until we get more suspects.....
THEN we use his ability

TaskManager · 2016-06-18 23:36:06

i think the 2nd investigation should be kept for later
i am pretty sure there will be time when it will be needed much more
but tbh i feel like rhaz should be checked

its your [kuba's] role and your choice after all tho

Kirby · 2016-06-19 00:22:33

oh i forgot to mention above, im able to kill someone every night, but i only get to 3 times. If that's useful to anyone~

realmaster42 · 2016-06-19 00:29:15

AlphaJon has been replaced by juliocesarsantos.

N1KF · 2016-06-19 00:33:21

AlphaJuliocesarsantos

Also I forgot to do my night action oops.

Different55 · 2016-06-19 00:33:25

Luka504 wrote:

Different55 wrote:
Come up with a better idea and if I like it better I'll switch. I'm not stuck on Luka, I guess he's more like a default setting for me when nothing else comes up at this point. More than that I want Creature to explain why he's making up reasons to lynch him.
It doesnt matter if Luka is town or nah, we will lynch him beacuse we have no leads
A plan that worked soooooo well last game.

We got retardedly unlucky last game, and the constant mislynches were only part of it. The mislynches, marco's constant misfires, Maxi's kills, and the mafia all played nearly equal parts in the town's death.
And it doesn't matter if Luka is town or not, I don't mind lynching him because he actively fights the town.

Luka504 wrote:
What is more benefical for mafia?
Lynching ~~a townie~~ me or not lynching at all?
FTFY
and do you really want me to answer that
Yes i do want you to anwser the question, without editing it.
What is more benefical for mafia?
Lynching a townie or not lynching at all

We're not discussing lynching a townie, we're discussing lynching you. Obviously the mafia would benefit more from lynching a townie than lynching nobody. Suggesting otherwise is dumb. BUT we're not talking about just a townie, we're talking about a person who hurts the town even when he's aligned with them. Trust me if I were mafia I wouldn't be trying to lynch you right now. I'd go for someone who actually had some clue of what was going on and leave all the people who have no clue all together. That's what they tried to do in the Undertale game.
BUT, if I were mafia and I did want you dead for some reason, why oh why would I be publicly shilling for your death? If I got you lynched and you were town obviously it would put a big ol target on my back. If I were mafia and I wanted you dead for some reason, I'd be killing you in the night where I couldn't be identified, not agreeing with the sketchy-as-heck Creature who still hasn't answered why he's made up like 3 fake reasons to lynch you.

You know what, now that I'm thinking about it more Creature is far more suspicious than you are from an alignment standpoint. I still think you're a liability to the town, but at least until I find out more about why Creature's going after you, you're a little less suspicious in my mind.

!unvote
!vote Creature

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Kuba if you can use your check go for Diff right now.

Go ahead, but it'll be a waste. I'm not aligned with mafia and I have no killing abilities either so whether his investigative ability is kill-based or alignment-based I'll show up clean.

maxi123 wrote:

but tbh i feel like rhaz should be checked

I wouldn't mind this. Just because I think he's a solid player and it'd be good to know whether he's on our side.

Different55 · 2016-06-19 00:33:58

Wow got all kinds of ninja'd

Different55 · 2016-06-19 00:34:46

marcoantonimsantos wrote:

Kirby wrote:
neither were mine, but i didnt hear anything about being controlled
Friendly reminder....

literally why say that out loud

TaskManager · 2016-06-19 02:21:01

Different55 wrote:

You know what, now that I'm thinking about it more Creature is far more suspicious than you are from an alignment standpoint. I still think you're a liability to the town, but at least until I find out more about why Creature's going after you, you're a little less suspicious in my mind.

but kuba investigated creature and got green result
sure there could be a godfather but who knows

kubapolish, Different55

Different55 · 2016-06-19 03:10:17

Dang it I forgot about that. Maybe N1KF's note keeping idea was a good one, now I'm like 50 times as conflicted. Creature seriously why are you acting so suspicious?

!unvote

Onjit · 2016-06-19 03:29:22

I found out from Marco that my night action is literally useless unless I survive to D3. And even then it's pretty useless.

GG

Evilbunny · 2016-06-19 05:03:22

What is our best town move, this is so frustrating. We can't seem to agree on anything, somebody has got to have some info but revealing it would also reveal themselves so it might not be worth saying. So we're just stuck on finger pointing and speculation, which we can't seem to agree on and if even if we did agree chances are we'd just lynch a townie because that's just how this game works.

My point is we are lost and blind and this day will probably be a waste and I'm upset.

Different55 · 2016-06-19 05:49:14

Alright, I don't have anything to lose, and it's not much but I have this. There are at least 3 roles with target swapping abilities of some sort. Kuba, myself, and someone else. Since there were two people who got controlled and the other one wasn't controlled by kuba obviously we have a third target swapper among us.

hummerz5 · 2016-06-19 06:11:11

maxi123 wrote:

i think the 2nd investigation should be kept for later
i am pretty sure there will be time when it will be needed much more
but tbh i feel like rhaz should be checked
its your [kuba's] role and your choice after all tho

I agree we should wait. If the swap turns out to be timely, then it'll be available. That, and the instant nature of the ability seems to warrant reservation.

@maxi123
Perhaps "night actions weren't spent" simply means your intended actions didn't take place. But, I could be way off mark.

Onjit wrote:

I found out from Marco that my night action is literally useless unless I survive to D3. And even then it's pretty useless.
GG

Of all the things I've spent time reading, your message is one of the more suspicious ones. (maybe I'm not reading enough!) I mean, the clearest thing to gain would be de facto protection because no one would (apparently) benefit from killing you until N3, giving you free reign for N2. Sure, this is all speculation, but eh.

Different55 wrote:

Dang it I forgot about that. Maybe N1KF's note keeping idea was a good one, now I'm like 50 times as conflicted. Creature seriously why are you acting so suspicious?
!unvote

Well, perhaps he's got daycop a strong role and doesn't want to oust quite yet. Probably could give him a berth or somethin'

@RhazzleFrazzle (RE Diff)
Arguably he isn't tunneling but grasping at straws. Luka's a considerable character and bouncing around suspects ( as opposed to simply sticking with luka) isn't too fruitful either.

@Evilbunny
you're getting a little bummed out about this game, eh? Perhaps we can wait a little bit. No, not in "game time" just IRL. Perhaps not everyone has checked in (who's keeping track?) and doesn't know the info they might not hide.
Tomorrow (still day 2) would be a great time to consider who hasn't stopped by and discuss narrowing down our choices.

so I added up the votes (unofficial. oh, and I didn't reset the vote counts from the day before. is that a thing?)
Kirby (1): Kubapolish
Luka504 (2): Creature, Bimps
Maxi123 (2): AlphaJon, RhazzleFrazzle
RhazzleFrazzle (1): N1KF
Different55 (1): RhazzleFrazzle

@Evilbunny: First thing's first, we need more than 6 people to vote at all. This is even more important seeing as how we're treating a majority system as a plurality setup. I personally am a fan of axing the folks who aren't doing anything.

Apparently there's been a few 3rd party folks in the past mafias. Any chance there's a serial killer or something in the mix? A bruce-esque system?

If any of this doesn't make sense, I'll hopefully be more awake tomorrow morning. Ask wth I mean then!

Kaleb · 2016-06-19 06:48:34

it was probably kuba,
since most people seem to think so.

Kaleb · 2016-06-19 06:50:48

Different55 wrote:

Alright, I don't have anything to lose, and it's not much but I have this. There are at least 3 roles with target swapping abilities of some sort. Kuba, myself, and someone else. Since there were two people who got controlled and the other one wasn't controlled by kuba obviously we have a third target swapper among us.

I wonder who the third Target Swaper is? ...

realmaster42 · 2016-06-19 10:19:23

Vote Count

Different55 (1): RhazzleFrazzle
The day will end once a majority (8) is reached.

Luka504 · 2016-06-19 12:14:48

Different55 wrote:

Luka504 wrote:
Different55 wrote:
Come up with a better idea and if I like it better I'll switch. I'm not stuck on Luka, I guess he's more like a default setting for me when nothing else comes up at this point. More than that I want Creature to explain why he's making up reasons to lynch him.
It doesnt matter if Luka is town or nah, we will lynch him beacuse we have no leads
A plan that worked soooooo well last game.
We got retardedly unlucky last game, and the constant mislynches were only part of it. The mislynches, marco's constant misfires, Maxi's kills, and the mafia all played nearly equal parts in the town's death.
And it doesn't matter if Luka is town or not, I don't mind lynching him because he actively fights the town.
Luka504 wrote:
What is more benefical for mafia?
Lynching ~~a townie~~ me or not lynching at all?
FTFY
and do you really want me to answer that
Yes i do want you to anwser the question, without editing it.
What is more benefical for mafia?
Lynching a townie or not lynching at all
We're not discussing lynching a townie, we're discussing lynching you. Obviously the mafia would benefit more from lynching a townie than lynching nobody. Suggesting otherwise is dumb. BUT we're not talking about just a townie, we're talking about a person who hurts the town even when he's aligned with them. Trust me if I were mafia I wouldn't be trying to lynch you right now.
Im sorry what?? You admitedly say im town and you want to lynch me?
That is not a town move Diff.
Also ,,If i was mafia i wouldnt be trying to lynch you,, is a pure lie.
You would try to lynch me if you are a mafia. You would have killed two birds with one stone.
1. You would lynch a townie.
2. You would have lynched the only person determined to stop the town from making more mislynches.
Now i dont believe you are a mafia (yet) but your posts are making me uneasy.
I'd go for someone who actually had some clue of what was going on and leave all the people who have no clue all together. That's what they tried to do in the Undertale game.
BUT, if I were mafia and I did want you dead for some reason, why oh why would I be publicly shilling for your death? If I got you lynched and you were town obviously it would put a big ol target on my back. If I were mafia and I wanted you dead for some reason, I'd be killing you in the night where I couldn't be identified, not agreeing with the sketchy-as-heck Creature who still hasn't answered why he's made up like 3 fake reasons to lynch you.
Those are all pretty good points actully. But again they dont have to be like you said.
You do indeed acknowledge that if i flip townie, you will probably be suspected.
So if you were a townie as well, WHY WOULD YOU LYNCH THE PERSON WHO U SAID WAS A TOWNIE!?
Oh its getting contradictory up in this place.
Oh dont even use the ,,You are helping the mafia,, argument.
I stated that i am not. Im trying to save weak townies from being pushed around by the mafia, being pushed around by people like you different.
I am indeed against D1 lynches for one main reason:
We dont know anything.
If someone started acting really suspicious i would gladly lynch them. But most of the time the town doesnt even give any good reasons to why they want a person lynched.
A lot like Creature who makes up lies to get me lynched. I dont believe Creature is mafia, i believe he is an executioner-like role.
However, Diff, you are making me feel really uneasy. You said you want a town member dead. YOU SAID IT.
You know what, now that I'm thinking about it more Creature is far more suspicious than you are from an alignment standpoint. I still think you're a liability to the town, but at least until I find out more about why Creature's going after you, you're a little less suspicious in my mind.
!unvote
!vote Creature
While Creatures motives are.... Questionable, i will let it slide considering he plays like an aggresive tiger every game he is in.
RhazzleFrazzle wrote:
Kuba if you can use your check go for Diff right now.
Go ahead, but it'll be a waste. I'm not aligned with mafia and I have no killing abilities either so whether his investigative ability is kill-based or alignment-based I'll show up clean.
maxi123 wrote:
but tbh i feel like rhaz should be checked
I wouldn't mind this. Just because I think he's a solid player and it'd be good to know whether he's on our side.

Official Everybody Edits Forums

#226 2016-06-18 22:33:10

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#227 2016-06-18 22:36:54

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#228 2016-06-18 22:37:14

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#229 2016-06-18 22:39:39

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#230 2016-06-18 22:46:50

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#231 2016-06-18 22:49:36

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#232 2016-06-18 23:01:31

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#233 2016-06-18 23:06:48

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#234 2016-06-18 23:36:06

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#235 2016-06-19 00:22:33

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#236 2016-06-19 00:29:15

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

AlphaJon has been replaced by juliocesarsantos.

#237 2016-06-19 00:33:21

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#238 2016-06-19 00:33:25

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#239 2016-06-19 00:33:58

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#240 2016-06-19 00:34:46

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

Friendly reminder....

#241 2016-06-19 02:21:01

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#242 2016-06-19 03:10:17

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#243 2016-06-19 03:29:22

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#244 2016-06-19 05:03:22

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#245 2016-06-19 05:49:14

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#246 2016-06-19 06:11:11

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#247 2016-06-19 06:48:34

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#248 2016-06-19 06:50:48

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

#249 2016-06-19 10:19:23

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

Vote Count

#250 2016-06-19 12:14:48

Re: EE Mafia 1 - Game Thread [CODE USERS WIN!]

Board footer