Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

TaskManager · 2016-03-20 19:17:26

Bimps wrote:

Creature wrote:
Zumza wrote:
Creature wrote:
Weak Town
Evilbunny
marcoantonimsantos
Maxi123
You have been the pioneers into voting maxi123 what made you change your mind?
He's looking genuine town for me, seeing how he's reacting. Also, if you see his plays, he normally looks to be defending someone.
well yeah but he's maxi, and you can see from the post he made earlier that he is annoying. lynch him because he sucks

ill shove a lynch rope up your **** upwoots to the right >>>
i copied ur phrase what u gonna do now hahah

Bimps · 2016-03-20 19:22:53

maxi123 wrote:

Bimps wrote:
Creature wrote:
Zumza wrote:
Creature wrote:
Weak Town
Evilbunny
marcoantonimsantos
Maxi123
You have been the pioneers into voting maxi123 what made you change your mind?
He's looking genuine town for me, seeing how he's reacting. Also, if you see his plays, he normally looks to be defending someone.
well yeah but he's maxi, and you can see from the post he made earlier that he is annoying. lynch him because he sucks
ill shove a lynch rope up your **** upwoots to the right >>>
i copied ur phrase what u gonna do now hahah

yeah my phrase from 4 months ago gj

SmittyW · 2016-03-20 19:25:52

^this is the part when we stop doing a quote-ception

I actually tried rereading the first few pages of the N1KF assault and the accusations were just so... stupid
Same goes with zumza. I was lazy and accepted him as scum because there was too much to read, but really there was no case. Only luka's last few posts convinced me he was scum.

Anak and luka both were extremely pushy but also kept voting for a no lynch? I know they are on separate teams but I wonder if there is a connection.

SmittyW · 2016-03-20 19:28:03

when did everyone forgive maxi so quickly? Is it because Bobithan asked us to cease hammering until he can investigate him?

realmaster42

Bobithan · 2016-03-20 19:36:10

SmittyW. wrote:

everyone

Who recently forgave maxi aside from Creature?

Kaslai · 2016-03-20 21:00:11

Looks like Bimps is going full retard... Never go full retard, Bimps.

Bobithan wrote:

I know doc can't protect every single person they want to, but idk who else would be a better protection target than the sheriff. I just need to hope they trust me enough to commit.

In my opinion, you should have held off on the hard claim until it was strictly necessary to prevent a lynch of someone innocent. While the mafia figures you're a PR now, they'll also figure you're protected each night, which splits the decision of any protective role in a very messy way.

Additionally, I'm inclined to see W24 as scum. He's very non-commital and always hedging. I'm not 100% sure we should trust Bobithan's claim though. Claiming Sheriff on day 2 is very... out there. Likewise, Gamemonger shouldn't be instantly elevated to a position of least suspicion either.

The only person so far I'm reasonably sure is town is Processor.

Pyromaniac, Onjit, AlphaJon

Bobithan · 2016-03-20 21:28:14

Kaslai wrote:

In my opinion, you should have held off on the hard claim until it was strictly necessary to prevent a lynch of someone innocent.

gdi yeah that probably would have been a better idea. sry for the nub move.

I still feel I haven't entirely gone to waste now, and it doesn't hurt to play it safe for a protective role to minimize the (albeit small) risk of protecting mafia instead.

Onjit · 2016-03-20 22:34:08

totes town

Pyromaniac
Bobithan
Creature
SmittyW.
Processor
Kaslai
Evilbunny
N1KF
AlphaJon
marcoantonimsantos
Gamemonger
Bimps
ZeldaXD
Zumza
W24
Calicara
Maxi123

totes mafia

SmittyW · 2016-03-20 22:46:39

How sweet you think everyone is good

There are still 4 mafia left, bucko

SmittyW · 2016-03-20 22:48:35

btw what's the prize for winning this game? Isn't there some money pool?

Bobithan · 2016-03-20 22:49:02

no thats a scale town on top to mafia on bottom im pretty sure and we dont get money we dont get anything

Processor · 2016-03-20 22:49:52

Seriously? Maxi is probably town.

SmittyW · 2016-03-20 22:50:19

Bobithan wrote:

we dont get money we dont get anything

!quit

Processor · 2016-03-20 22:50:33

Bimps likely town too.

Processor · 2016-03-20 22:51:32

Gamemonger and W24 smell so scummy. Time to write a full analysis and then make make a case on them.

SmittyW · 2016-03-20 22:53:20

Processor wrote:

Gamemonger and W24 smell so scummy. Time to write a full analysis and then make make a case on them.

Bobithan wrote:

Last night I investigated Gamemonger and got a town result.

Bobithan · 2016-03-20 22:59:04

Could be godfather. Not all results are perfect.

Calicara · 2016-03-20 23:54:31

I'm sorry for inactivity. Last night I went out drinking, and today I had butt tons of HW. But after today I'm free all week, so I'll read through the 30+ pages of this thread tomorrow night. All I have to say so far today is, I trust Bobithan's hard claim for now (I see no reason not to.) I also agree that he revealed too early, but at the same time hopefully he can help (if there is a doctor.) It's impossible for me to make a hard claim as a citizen, but that's pretty much what I am. And I feel sucky, because I wish I could help more, but I'll do what I can. I'll give reads tomorrow.

W24 · 2016-03-20 23:57:37

Processor wrote:

Gamemonger and W24 smell so scummy. Time to write a full analysis and then make make a case on them.

Bobithan checked gamemonger and got town.

ZeldaXD · 2016-03-21 00:04:58

Guys yesterday at night I woke up for some milk and I saw W24 with a black bag

TaskManager · 2016-03-21 00:24:55

W24 wrote:

Processor wrote:
Gamemonger and W24 smell so scummy. Time to write a full analysis and then make make a case on them.
Bobithan checked gamemonger and got town.

Bobithan wrote:

Could be godfather. Not all results are perfect.

Processor · 2016-03-21 01:33:52

Okay, it is time for PoE!

(Sorry Rhazh, I know you don't like it when people do this)

Going for scum vs not scum is hard, because we have two groups. Both scum are going to scumhunt during the day. Therefore I will analyze people only based on whether they are leaning orange or not. I might bother doing a similar list for red mafia too.

NOT ORANGE

Very confident
Processor: I was the person who really pushed toward the luka lynch.
Zelda & Marc & W24: They didn't switch over to Zumza, they are definitely not orange.
Bobithan: He hammered the vote on Luka.
SmittyW: Thanks to him switching votes, many others followed and we managed to lynch the right person.
Creature: He did take his vote off Zumza to prevent a hammer and seemed open to vote on Luka.
Kaslai: Put down a vote, there was no pressure on him.
Pyromaniac: Just like Creature, he was open to voting luka.

Pretty confident
Zumza: He did vote on luka, but he gets less credit because he had no other options. I dislike the whole Anak vs Zumza thing, it was very pointless, but I don't think it makes him scummy.

Rather confident
Maxi123: I little concerning that he was defended by luka, but in the end he wasn't too hesistant to lynch him, he gets a green card for today.
AlphaJon: Voted on Luka twice, once when he was at L-2.
Calicara: She seemed open to lynching luka.
N1KF: I was going to write a long review on this guy, but... nah. N1KF blaming him does make him look red/town though.

Unsure
Bimps: Haven't seen much from him yet.

Alarming:
Onjit: Ugh, he votes for Luka, then 180s back, saying it was just a joke. He does seriously participate in N1KF and Zumza pushes, never explains why he didn't want Luka lynched. Suspecious.

Scummy:
Gamemonger: He voted for N1KF, he voted for Zumza, he conciously did not participate in the Luka movement by lurking.
Evilbunny: Even worse than Gamemonger. He does try to help Luka out. Doesn't participate without seriously stating why.

VERY ORANGE

As you can see, I do recommend going for Evilbunny or Gamemonger, as they seem to be the only two players who completely avoided Luka or outright helped him out.

Processor · 2016-03-21 01:33:57

Now, here is my case on EB:

Evilbunny wrote:

I really hope you guys start taking this more seriously day 2. We shouldn't have 6 pages of spam everyday.
Creature seems to be the only person doing anything, and he's only throwing empty votes at people, so once 2 of us are DEAD tomorrow, I expect things to be more serious.
Also because we should lynch today and he has the most votes right now:
!vote N1KF

Shout out to make sure a person is killed that night. Takes the opportunity to vote on N1KF, only stating confbias as reasoning.

Evilbunny wrote:

Luka504 wrote:
I dont care if you are a doctor or whatever.
I think what he meant by this was "I am willing to lynch you, even at the risk of you being a doctor"
We (people that voted for N1KF) are all guilty of that, even if we didn't actually say it.
Also Creature is pulling the mafia equivalent of "It's just a prank, bro": "It's just a pressure vote, bro"
and Marco could you stop with the "hidden" messages. If you have something to say, just say it.

Defending Luka, this is his first and only interaction with him.
He doesn't go on to defend any other points, lurks around while the push on luka is happening.

Evilbunny wrote:

I'm gonna write my responses in orange

Please don't take this seriously, it is silly, but I can't stop thinking that a town member would stop to think twice before choosing orange as their color.

Evilbunny wrote:

mfw Luka was mafia and I look like an idiot now

It might be a little too late now, like I've said, you never really justified not voting for Luka.

!vote Evilbunny

Bimps · 2016-03-21 01:36:16

proc i am town you dumper

Creature · 2016-03-21 01:40:09

!vote Evilbunny

For now, until I make a case on one of my scum reads.

Also, if Bobithan is town, Gamemonger must also be, I don't really see a godfather play on him.

Official Everybody Edits Forums

#726 2016-03-20 19:17:26

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#727 2016-03-20 19:22:53

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#728 2016-03-20 19:25:52

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#729 2016-03-20 19:28:03

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#730 2016-03-20 19:36:10

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#731 2016-03-20 21:00:11

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#732 2016-03-20 21:28:14

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#733 2016-03-20 22:34:08

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#734 2016-03-20 22:46:39

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#735 2016-03-20 22:48:35

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#736 2016-03-20 22:49:02

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#737 2016-03-20 22:49:52

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#738 2016-03-20 22:50:19

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#739 2016-03-20 22:50:33

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#740 2016-03-20 22:51:32

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#741 2016-03-20 22:53:20

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#742 2016-03-20 22:59:04

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#743 2016-03-20 23:54:31

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#744 2016-03-20 23:57:37

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#745 2016-03-21 00:04:58

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#746 2016-03-21 00:24:55

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#747 2016-03-21 01:33:52

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#748 2016-03-21 01:33:57

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#749 2016-03-21 01:36:16

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

#750 2016-03-21 01:40:09

Re: Mafia 6 game thread:Multiball (Town wins!)

Board footer