Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

RhazzleFrazzle · 2016-01-16 21:56:11

Creature wrote:

I am lynching anyone who isn't talking at all. First, they won't make difference because they aren't helping at all. Second, they're just trying to get less attention and making our readings harder.

Needless filler. Aiming for Town cred.

Creature wrote:

Hostage wrote:
another cliche:
ready to die on night 1.
Another cliche:
bad post is suspicious.

Why make this post and then make this one?

Creature wrote:

Scum Reading D1 is the same as guessing a lottery number.

Is this a way to excuse yourself from taking a stance on me vs Hostage?

Creature wrote:

I don't even think you're serious at all, but if you want me to say something then:
ZeldaXD started with what looks like a joke, Hostage decided to take it somewhat seriously and you're now arguing with each other about someone being suspicious.

Yes now are you going to start taking a stance on us? You've already established a suspicion on Hostage. Why aren't you pushing on it?

Creature wrote:

Zoey2070, why are you softclaiming D1?

Fishing for Zoey's role. ZOEY DO NOT HARDCLAIM.

Zoey2070 · 2016-01-16 21:57:25

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

ZOEY DO NOT HARDCLAIM

don't tell me what to do
i'm vampire hunter lol

(that's a joke btw)

RhazzleFrazzle · 2016-01-16 21:58:30

Anyways Creature is at the top of my scum list right now. I forgot to add that he feels like he wants to hide under the radar as well. His lack of contribution worries me.

Anak · 2016-01-16 22:03:23

Rhaz I actually had no idea you were playing I just got really confused bc I thought you were overseeing everything and making comments and idk why

RhazzleFrazzle · 2016-01-16 22:04:20

Anak wrote:

Rhaz I actually had no idea you were playing I just got really confused bc I thought you were overseeing everything and making comments and idk why

uw0t?

Anak · 2016-01-16 22:07:20

Yeah idk I thought you were just like "time to help the children out"

some woman

RhazzleFrazzle · 2016-01-16 22:08:15

Believe me as much as I wanted to rant at you all in the last two games I try to not influence games I'm not in.

Creature · 2016-01-16 22:22:29

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Anyways Creature is at the top of my scum list right now. I forgot to add that he feels like he wants to hide under the radar as well. His lack of contribution worries me.

This is D1 geez, you can't force everyone to show their leads asap.

However, you're looking very scummy by attacking everybody who's saying something. You're in general pointing someone's personality as if he was actually scum. You're likely manipulating town into believing you just because you're experienced and stuff, It's weird how nobody besides me is suspecting you.
Regarding Hostage, I don't even need to point he's being suspicious at all. And I wasn't fishing Zoey's role, I never pointed out Zoey was suspicious at all. I don't think Zoey is mafia, but I am not getting fooled again.
Who's saying what you consider fluff can be town as equally as scum, accusing everybody for saying fluff is a scum strategy to get mislynches. Stop trying to lead mislynches.

RhazzleFrazzle · 2016-01-16 22:37:33

Creature wrote:

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:
Anyways Creature is at the top of my scum list right now. I forgot to add that he feels like he wants to hide under the radar as well. His lack of contribution worries me.
This is D1 geez, you can't force everyone to show their leads asap.
However, you're looking very scummy by attacking everybody who's saying something. You're in general pointing someone's personality as if he was actually scum. You're likely manipulating town into believing you just because you're experienced and stuff, It's weird how nobody besides me is suspecting you.
Regarding Hostage, I don't even need to point he's being suspicious at all. And I wasn't fishing Zoey's role, I never pointed out Zoey was suspicious at all. I don't think Zoey is mafia, but I am not getting fooled again.
Who's saying what you consider fluff can be town as equally as scum, accusing everybody for saying fluff is a scum strategy to get mislynches. Stop trying to lead mislynches.

Responses to what I bolded:

Well why wouldn't I be pushing someone if I think they're scum? I'd rather look deeper into my initial reads than see something scummy and ignore it. Also I really don't want people to agree with me just because of my experience. Disagreement furthers discussion IMO.

And yes, you were trying to fish Zoey's role. You had no reason at all to point out her softclaim. It's best to not paint a big red target on one of our PRs. You may be used to Town of Salem where the only way to defend yourself is to claim a role, but here since we have days of discussion time it's not reccomended. Best for the PRs to stay hidden from the Mafia. Only the Mafia would want to find out the PRs at this point anyways.

Creature · 2016-01-17 01:36:17

Oh, I noticed I misread, softclaiming wasn't really the right word to use, but I didn't intend to fish anyone's role.

About you, I have a feeling you might be as uninformed as the rest of the town, we'd better not conclude anything or it might cause problems, however, I am looking on you.

Regarding fluffing, it's not really a problem, most of the town is totally confuse at the start, and fluffing might help us catch up what's happening. If someone has been just fluffing all the time, then we can just point him.

AlphaJon · 2016-01-17 02:02:09

Come on guys, this is D1 and there's already 3 pages of arguing over zoey "to be or not to be" scum. We can't accuse anyone on D1 because there's no data, besides some speculations based on posts.

RhazzleFrazzle · 2016-01-17 02:03:46

Jonathan1003 wrote:

Come on guys, this is D1 and there's already 3 pages of arguing over zoey "to be or not to be" scum. We can't accuse anyone on D1 because there's no data, besides some speculations based on posts.

Speculations based on posts is how the game is played. Besides, what are we gonna have tomorrow? Our only investigative can't do anything until one of the Mafia dies, and even then he can only confirm 1 Mafia.

Calicara · 2016-01-17 05:09:44

Hi I'm here. Sorry for not posting so much, I went out to party tonight. Anyway luck to town and this is mostly a filler post so Processor doesn't kick me :d

Hostage · 2016-01-17 11:34:12

Jonathan1003 wrote:

Come on guys, this is D1 and there's already 3 pages of arguing over zoey "to be or not to be" scum. We can't accuse anyone on D1 because there's no data, besides some speculations based on posts.

It was a joke,ffs

Anak · 2016-01-17 14:06:02

Hostage wrote:

Jonathan1003 wrote:
Come on guys, this is D1 and there's already 3 pages of arguing over zoey "to be or not to be" scum. We can't accuse anyone on D1 because there's no data, besides some speculations based on posts.
It was a joke,ffs

Well obviously that didn't come across so if you're going to make a joke just leave it to one post or not at all.
If you're going to accuse someone you may as well be serious about it.

Onjit · 2016-01-17 14:06:19

!endday

why is d1 even a thing

like really

Anak · 2016-01-17 14:07:58

Processor wrote:

The day cannot be skipped

Onjit · 2016-01-17 14:09:18

mindless speculation is is then

Evilbunny

AlphaJon · 2016-01-17 14:10:38

RhazzleFrazzle wrote:

Speculations based on posts is how the game is played. Besides, what are we gonna have tomorrow? Our only investigative can't do anything until one of the Mafia dies, and even then he can only confirm 1 Mafia.

You're right, the posts and night results are basically the only way we can try to guess who the mafia can be.

Hostage wrote:

It was a joke,ffs

OK, it may have been a joke at the beginning, but you pushed it too hard, look, it has now turned into an argument, and tbh it's not getting better with time.
However, you successfully managed to make the mafia not want to target you N1, if you are town, because you got quite a few people against you, and if they kill you they lose that.
I also doubt Zoey will be killed N1 too, because this way, it can keep on going.

Pyromaniac · 2016-01-17 15:45:07

Guys pls. Why would we lynch day 1? We know nothings except that rhaz is needlessly aggressive. Saying zoey is mafia based on her last games is silly. It's called the gamblers fallacy. Assuming something is more likely to happen based on past experiences when really it's independent. (This is assuming that roles are picked randomly)

To be honest I'd be more apt to go for rhaz. Very pushy.

Hostage · 2016-01-17 15:54:12

Pyromaniac wrote:

Guys pls. Why would we lynch day 1? We know nothings except that rhaz is needlessly aggressive. Saying zoey is mafia based on her last games is silly. It's called the gamblers fallacy. Assuming something is more likely to happen based on past experiences when really it's independent. (This is assuming that roles are picked randomly)
To be honest I'd be more apt to go for rhaz. Very pushy.

Good point,but lets not jump to conclusions and lynch rhaz,you'd totally ruin your own point if you did that the next day

RhazzleFrazzle · 2016-01-17 15:58:41

Pyromaniac wrote:

Guys pls. Why would we lynch day 1? We know nothings except that rhaz is needlessly aggressive. Saying zoey is mafia based on her last games is silly. It's called the gamblers fallacy. Assuming something is more likely to happen based on past experiences when really it's independent. (This is assuming that roles are picked randomly)
To be honest I'd be more apt to go for rhaz. Very pushy.

I'm not saying she's Mafia because RNG. I'm pushing her because she was a bit inactive D1 in the last two games. I'm judging behavior and not RNG.

Pyromaniac · 2016-01-17 16:08:33

Hostage wrote:

Pyromaniac wrote:
Guys pls. Why would we lynch day 1? We know nothings except that rhaz is needlessly aggressive. Saying zoey is mafia based on her last games is silly. It's called the gamblers fallacy. Assuming something is more likely to happen based on past experiences when really it's independent. (This is assuming that roles are picked randomly)
To be honest I'd be more apt to go for rhaz. Very pushy.
Good point,but lets not jump to conclusions and lynch rhaz,you'd totally ruin your own point if you did that the next day

Not necessarily, because I'd be lynching him based on aggressive behavior THIS game. Regardless, I'm not saying we should definitely lynch him, just that he makes more sense than zoey.

RhazzleFrazzle · 2016-01-17 16:32:41

Pyromaniac wrote:

Hostage wrote:
Pyromaniac wrote:
Guys pls. Why would we lynch day 1? We know nothings except that rhaz is needlessly aggressive. Saying zoey is mafia based on her last games is silly. It's called the gamblers fallacy. Assuming something is more likely to happen based on past experiences when really it's independent. (This is assuming that roles are picked randomly)
To be honest I'd be more apt to go for rhaz. Very pushy.
Good point,but lets not jump to conclusions and lynch rhaz,you'd totally ruin your own point if you did that the next day
Not necessarily, because I'd be lynching him based on aggressive behavior THIS game. Regardless, I'm not saying we should definitely lynch him, just that he makes more sense than zoey.

What are your thoughts on Hostage?

Pyromaniac · 2016-01-17 17:24:13

I believe him when he says it was a joke to lynch zoey lol, i dont know why everyone jumped on that

Hostage

Official Everybody Edits Forums

#76 2016-01-16 21:56:11

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#77 2016-01-16 21:57:25

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#78 2016-01-16 21:58:30

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#79 2016-01-16 22:03:23

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#80 2016-01-16 22:04:20

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#81 2016-01-16 22:07:20

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#82 2016-01-16 22:08:15

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#83 2016-01-16 22:22:29

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#84 2016-01-16 22:37:33

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#85 2016-01-17 01:36:17

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#86 2016-01-17 02:02:09

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#87 2016-01-17 02:03:46

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#88 2016-01-17 05:09:44

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#89 2016-01-17 11:34:12

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#90 2016-01-17 14:06:02

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#91 2016-01-17 14:06:19

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#92 2016-01-17 14:07:58

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#93 2016-01-17 14:09:18

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#94 2016-01-17 14:10:38

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#95 2016-01-17 15:45:07

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#96 2016-01-17 15:54:12

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#97 2016-01-17 15:58:41

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#98 2016-01-17 16:08:33

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#99 2016-01-17 16:32:41

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

#100 2016-01-17 17:24:13

Re: Mafia 3: The Hunt for RhazzleFrazzle's Gun - Game Topic

Board footer