Official Everybody Edits Forums

Chico

Guest

Boss Rating

I've seen alot of bad bosses lately, and I decided to make a topic, in which you could find good bosses. I will be judging all kinds of bosses, on the following points:

-Originality (30 points)
-Variety (30 points)
-Diffuculty (30 points)
-Rewards (10 points)

0-19 points:
20-39 points:
40-59 points:
60-79 points:
80-99 points:
100 points:

When I judged a boss, I will edit it in in this post. If you would like to judge with me, PM me, or post in this topic. If you want your boss to be judged, post in this topic, and post a time(s) when the boss will be online. But watch out! I can always sneek into your boss, and judge it! So be careful!

Judged bosses:

(http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWAAgpWGSXa0I) or (http://beta.everybodyedits.com/games/PWAAgpWGSXa0I)
Tiger Boss
Originality: 20/30 Good use of arrows, but no outstanding things I have never seen before.
Variety: 20/30 3 or 4 different types, became repetitive after a few times, but still good.
Diffuculty: 27/30 Close to perfect.
Rewards: 4/10 1 reward: Your name gets written down.
Total: 71/100
Rank:
Judged by Chico

(http://everybodyedits.com/games/PW1GwW3zOFa0I) or(http://beta.everybodyedits.com/games/PW1GwW3zOFa0I)
BOSS TO CODE
Originality: 12/30 Dot trails, tight fit, I was surprised I didn't see hookjumps.
Variety: 20/30 Quite a few different types.
Diffuculty: 18/30 Pretty easy.
Rewards: 2/10 Crown.
Total: 52/100
Rank:
Judged by Chico

(http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWAEj0EJ_Ta0I) or (http://beta.everybodyedits.com/games/PWAEj0EJ_Ta0I)
Chat Bubble Boss
Originality: 25/30 Some sexy arrow things I didn't see before.
Variety: 25/30 Didn't spot the same challenge twice, a bit repetitive red/green stuff.
Diffuculty: 23/30: Didn't score 20 because it was a little, just a little, too hard.
Rewards: 2/10 Crown.
Total: 75/100
Rank:
Judged by Chico

(http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWABCZn9qJa0I) or (http://beta.everybodyedits.com/games/PWABCZn9qJa0I)
Astral Challenge
Originality: 10/30 Copy, simple red/green, alot of cliché stuff.
Variety: 10/30 No thank you, copy was already annoying the first time.
Diffuculty: 15/30 Very easy.
Rewards: 8/10 You get a coin when you win a boss, when you get enough you can pass to the next level.
Total: 43/100
Rank:
Judged by Chico

(http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWAOifPj2Ha0I) or (http://beta.everybodyedits.com/games/PWAOifPj2Ha0I)
Water Boss
Originality: 20/30 Lots of cool challenges.
Variety: 20/30 Lots of things, a bit repetitive red/green stuff.
Diffuculty: 25/30 Hard red/green stuff, very good.
Rewards: 6/10 Crown and coins leading to a special area with minis.
Total: 70/100
Rank:
Judged by Chico

(http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWF_jCE8dya0I) or (http://beta.everybodyedits.com/games/PWF_jCE8dya0I)
Massive Boss
Originality: 12/30 No outstanding things, lots of clichés.
Variety: 18/30 Quite a few different things.
Diffuculty: 20/30 A bit too easy.
Rewards: 4/10 Coins leading to special area.
Total: 54/100
Rank:
Judged by Chico

Last edited by Chico (Apr 25 2011 2:54:26 am)

Jeremy

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

I'll judge with you
EDIT: What do you mean by Variety?

Last edited by Jeremy (Apr 23 2011 3:30:56 am)

Chico

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

I'll judge with you
EDIT: What do you mean by Variety?

Basically the number of different bosses the boss does. Not copy (which sucks anyways) only, but far more. It's different from originality. You would decrease points on originality if the boss uses alot of hookjumps, and that kind of stuff.

PM me results on a boss when you judged one, and I will edit it in.

Last edited by Chico (Apr 23 2011 3:35:10 am)

NikK

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

http://img228.imageshack.us/img228/7272/tigerboss.jpg
(http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWAAgpWGSXa0I) or (http://beta.everybodyedits.com/games/PWAAgpWGSXa0I)
Tiger Boss
Originality: 20/30 good use of arrows, but no outstanding things I have never seen before.
Variety: 20/30 3 or 4 different types, became repetitive after a few times, but still good.
Diffuculty: 18/20 close to perfect.
Decoration: 15/15 what a nice tiger!
Rewards: 2/5 1 reward: Your name gets written down.
Total: 75/100
Rank:
Judged by Chico

They used animator, you know.

Btw, I have a boss, but I only put it on when I'm bored and I have nothing else to do 1xd1

Chico

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

http://img228.imageshack.us/img228/7272/tigerboss.jpg
(http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWAAgpWGSXa0I) or (http://beta.everybodyedits.com/games/PWAAgpWGSXa0I)
Tiger Boss
Originality: 20/30 good use of arrows, but no outstanding things I have never seen before.
Variety: 20/30 3 or 4 different types, became repetitive after a few times, but still good.
Diffuculty: 18/20 close to perfect.
Decoration: 15/15 what a nice tiger!
Rewards: 2/5 1 reward: Your name gets written down.
Total: 75/100
Rank:
Judged by Chico

They used animator, you know.

Btw, I have a boss, but I only put it on when I'm bored and I have nothing else to do 1xd1

It's still a nice tiger

Silverheart

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

could you rate astral challenge, it's on currently.

Last edited by Silverheart (Apr 23 2011 2:37:55 pm)

Chico

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

Added Chat Bubble Boss to the list of judged bosses.

Chico

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

could you rate astral challenge, it's on currently.

I am in, my name is JimmyDG

Calicara

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

The tiger boss should not be rated. It was made using animator, which imports the blocks right into the level.

Honestly I don't like bosses. I feel humiliated in a way having to do what the player wants me to do. Besides even when you do win, the crown never last forever.

Chico

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

The tiger boss should not be rated. It was made using animator, which imports the blocks right into the level.

Honestly I don't like bosses. I feel humiliated in a way having to do what the player wants me to do. Besides even when you do win, the crown never last forever.

Is there any kind of proof it was made using animator? Until then, I will assume it was made by hand, and therefore an excellent piece of art. ''Innocent until proven otherwise.'' About the crown never lasting forever, people only using a crown as a reward get only 1 point out of 5 for rewards.

Added Astral Challenge to the list of judged bosses.

Calicara

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

The tiger boss should not be rated. It was made using animator, which imports the blocks right into the level.

Honestly I don't like bosses. I feel humiliated in a way having to do what the player wants me to do. Besides even when you do win, the crown never last forever.

Is there any kind of proof it was made using animator? Until then, I will assume it was made by hand, and therefore an excellent piece of art. ''Innocent until proven otherwise.'' About the crown never lasting forever, people only using a crown as a reward get only 1 point out of 5 for rewards.

Added Astral Challenge to the list of judged bosses.

Chico you can tell the difference between hand-made art, and animator.

Bee, makes real art.

Linus21, most likely uses animator

That tiger has amazing shading and technique, it would be close to impossible to make it without animator, unless you are like Bee. But since the tinychat link is for Linus21 I'm 99.9% sure it's animated.

NikK

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

The tiger boss should not be rated. It was made using animator, which imports the blocks right into the level.

Honestly I don't like bosses. I feel humiliated in a way having to do what the player wants me to do. Besides even when you do win, the crown never last forever.

Is there any kind of proof it was made using animator? Until then, I will assume it was made by hand, and therefore an excellent piece of art. ''Innocent until proven otherwise.'' About the crown never lasting forever, people only using a crown as a reward get only 1 point out of 5 for rewards.

Added Astral Challenge to the list of judged bosses.

Your proof? Linus21's tinychat, random blocks for shading, too awesome. Just think about it.

Chico

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

The tiger boss should not be rated. It was made using animator, which imports the blocks right into the level.

Honestly I don't like bosses. I feel humiliated in a way having to do what the player wants me to do. Besides even when you do win, the crown never last forever.

Is there any kind of proof it was made using animator? Until then, I will assume it was made by hand, and therefore an excellent piece of art. ''Innocent until proven otherwise.'' About the crown never lasting forever, people only using a crown as a reward get only 1 point out of 5 for rewards.

Added Astral Challenge to the list of judged bosses.

Chico you can tell the difference between hand-made art, and animator.

Bee, makes real art.

Linus21, most likely uses animator

That tiger has amazing shading and technique, it would be close to impossible to make it without animator, unless you are like Bee. But since the tinychat link is for Linus21 I'm 99.9% sure it's animated.

It's extremely hard to judge someone on something like that. If I remove points from that level because of the decoration, because we THINK it is ee animated (Yes, I know that's the most likely situation.) I will have to check ALL levels if they are ee animated. That is simply impossible. So, in that case, in order for everything to be fair, I don't think about ee animated stuff. It's impossible to judge.

Last edited by Chico (Apr 23 2011 11:52:41 pm)

Chico

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

Added Water Boss to the list of judged bosses.

WELL_

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

The tiger boss should not be rated. It was made using animator, which imports the blocks right into the level.

Honestly I don't like bosses. I feel humiliated in a way having to do what the player wants me to do. Besides even when you do win, the crown never last forever.

Is there any kind of proof it was made using animator? Until then, I will assume it was made by hand, and therefore an excellent piece of art. ''Innocent until proven otherwise.'' About the crown never lasting forever, people only using a crown as a reward get only 1 point out of 5 for rewards.

Added Astral Challenge to the list of judged bosses.

lemme see.. google:tiger:
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_sFqkluIPwKA/S … +Growl.jpg

Chico

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

The tiger boss should not be rated. It was made using animator, which imports the blocks right into the level.

Honestly I don't like bosses. I feel humiliated in a way having to do what the player wants me to do. Besides even when you do win, the crown never last forever.

Is there any kind of proof it was made using animator? Until then, I will assume it was made by hand, and therefore an excellent piece of art. ''Innocent until proven otherwise.'' About the crown never lasting forever, people only using a crown as a reward get only 1 point out of 5 for rewards.

Added Astral Challenge to the list of judged bosses.

lemme see.. google:tiger:
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_sFqkluIPwKA/S … +Growl.jpg

Haha, that is pretty decisive. In that case, how would you all judge the decoration? It's hard to make sure something is ee animated.... so that is why I ignored it in the first place.

Chico

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

Added Massive Boss to the list of judged bosses.

Jeremy

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

Oh. I am the boss on the Tiger boss on. Look at the god: "ITS ME!!!!"

wallacenew

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

Is there any kind of proof it was made using animator? Until then, I will assume it was made by hand, and therefore an excellent piece of art. ''Innocent until proven otherwise.'' About the crown never lasting forever, people only using a crown as a reward get only 1 point out of 5 for rewards.

Added Astral Challenge to the list of judged bosses.

lemme see.. google:tiger:
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_sFqkluIPwKA/S … +Growl.jpg

Haha, that is pretty decisive. In that case, how would you all judge the decoration? It's hard to make sure something is ee animated.... so that is why I ignored it in the first place.

So i think the Decorations Part may contain less marks and become less important.

Calicara

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

Well all I am saying is things that are animated should be considered "cheating" as far as decoration goes, because the owner did not actually make it, they imported it. Also I noticed someone posted the actual original picture of the tiger so you have plenty of proof. And if you want to make real ratings you should consider the fact that some things were animated because if it was not made by hand it should not get as many points.

supadorf24

Member

Joined: 2015-02-26

Posts: 2,675

Re: Boss Rating

Just take our word for it. We've all had enough EE exerience to know for a fact that that was uploaded. No proof necessary. We can all tell the difference between handmade and uploaded art. Once you've seen enough of it, you can tell almost instantly if something was uploaded.

Chico

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

Well all I am saying is things that are animated should be considered "cheating" as far as decoration goes, because the owner did not actually make it, they imported it. Also I noticed someone posted the actual original picture of the tiger so you have plenty of proof. And if you want to make real ratings you should consider the fact that some things were animated because if it was not made by hand it should not get as many points.

Your advice is noted. Removed the decoration part and made Diffuculty worth 30 points, and rewards 10.

Luuu

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

i love all these worlds.;)
nice maps, great jog!!!:)

Chico

Guest

Re: Boss Rating

Rejudged Water Boss.