EEC Contest Circuit

Creature · Before February 2015

I could organizate the music contest.

Noctis · Before February 2015

So when will our points be distributed?

Last edited by Noctis (Mar 1 2014 3:03:35 pm)

Creature · Before February 2015

Itsmeandersonlol wrote:

So when will our points be distributed?

When all rounds be judged.

dragonranger · Before February 2015

I was bored, and I want to "extend" my skills in picture makin...
And so...
Here's about 20 min of work -_-

P.S: Nice map muffin and can't wait for the collage

Last edited by Dragonranger (Mar 1 2014 4:54:41 pm)

Muffin · Before February 2015

I completed them all

I was bored

dragonranger · Before February 2015

Personally, I think you should make the themes more varied.
Maybe even give a choice of 2-3.
Especially as, it's pretty boring just playing through, and seeing near to the same art.
Also, maybe abstract themes could make it varied.

For example, fear, could be anything, from a fear of heights, drowning e.t.c and makes the contestants have to think harder about what they want to make.

Although, ignore this if you were already planning this for later themes e.t.c, this is just my though on the themes

Master1 · Before February 2015

lol nice muffin, and great picture Dragonranger :O
-
Just a quick update on what I'm doing right now:
I'm currently 3/14 done with judging. I'll be posting my personal level ratings, and short reviews for why I scored them the way I did, when I'm done. When I post my ratings though, do not act like you have already won/lost. My ratings are not final, as the other judges still have to judge too.

Raon · Before February 2015

Raon's Judging List
Please note that all of my judging will be completely objective and honest, but you should not let yourself influenced by my opinion.
I will do the judging organised in domains (art; minis; gameplay; and the final result, overall)

Rating means perfect score.
Rating means disastruous performance.
[+]       means overall score was boosted by a perfect score achievement.
+          means the level contained a small special thing that i specially liked and i gave it some bonus points on a certain domain.
-          means the level contained a small thing that i hated, or i disliked very much, and made give it a more negative score on a certain domain.
1. Skullz16 & Sensei1
Well, your level was an overall mediocre experience.
You used a lot of eye-raping bricks, where alternatives could have been really easy to implement. The building and the ground could have used a bit more shading, but i like the small touch you gave to the sand hills that makes the light beams coming from the sun reflect in a nice way from the ground. I also iked the look of the sky, well blended and nice choice of colors.
Minis were not that satisfying, lacking originality, but on a good note, they were easy and fun. Too bad the gameplay experienced was affected by the use of eye-rape backgrounds (-).
Overall, the level is ok, but feels somewhat unfinished, and the minis are not really blending with the art, in order to create a story.
Art: 6/10    Minis: 6/10    Gameplay: 3/10    Overall: 5/10
I know you guys and you can do unconsiderably more and better than that, seriously, why not try your best next time?

2. Calicara & Esox270
I'll go straight to the point. Art is simple yet good, and the minimap is appealing. Not overflooded with shading or decorations, but art style is well blended with level size and minis, having a more of a relaxing, comfortable gameplay. It also seems to contain a plot, monsters being a nice touch, and minis were wll fitted into the level design. Good Job.
Art: 6/10 Minis: 7/10 Gameplay: 7/10 Overall: 7/10

3. Theditor & Stagecrew
Great level, and the fact that you recreated an historical event is even greater (a + for that). Art is simple yet full of messages, and i really love the way you did the tank, and the ingenious discrete message hidden in the palm The collors are also subjective, and meaningfull. You did a great job on making super simple and super fun minis too, and i love that.
Art: 7/10 Minis: 8/10 Gameplay: 9/10 Overall: 8/10

4. Creature & Blizzard10
I hate to be mean on reviews, but i promised to myself to be fair and point everything according to their merits. I can't really give a mark on the art, as there is almost no art to judge only 3 colors, no shading and basic shaping is nothing close to an eye-stimulating experience when working with pixel art. Good think that you remembered to add some minis, so the world isn't that much of a litteral desert......
I'm really dissapointed of you.
Art: 1/10 Minis: 4/10 Gameplay: 4/10 Overall: 2.5/10

5. JaWapa & Superbowlboundraven
A good level, with great art and great minis. Really calm atmosphere, relaxing, and eye appealing I really like the ground shading. Nothing more to say.
Art: 7.5/10 Minis: 8/10 Gameplay: 9/10 Overall: 8.5/10

6. Chiscorey & Toxic
Here we can see a majestic contrast. Amazing, astonishing art for a world with this size, but minis that make you punch a palm tree in the coconut. Sky is so well blended, trees have a good shade and the color picking is done great. On the other side, minis are lacking integration with the art, being nothing more than mini boxes above the art. They are hard, and some of them are ragey, but at least the concept is ok. The blue coins were nice, but on the 2nd mini i hated the fact you could loose the checkpoint you were on in favour of a previous one. Simply ragey and unfair.
Art: 10/10 (perfect score) Minis: 5/10 Gameplay: 7/10 Overall: 8.5 [+] /10

7. Kentiya
At the first sight, the level seemed fun and interesting. The plot is cool, art is very awesome and well shaded, and planning was good. Minis are very well integrated with the concept and the art, and were fun overall, but i dislike the fact that you used invisible bricks. I just hate them, and i consider them a cheating advantage, sorry. (a - for that) Overall, you did a really good job, i like it!
Art: 8/10 Minis: 7/10 Gameplay: 7.5/10 Overall: 7.75/10

8. Muftwin
A cool level, with an original concept for the first round of EECCC. I was fooled at first by the posibility of having more choices, but i still found the minis to be a bit ragey. Art was not something extraordinaire, but it's easy to see you've put some effort into making this level. A nice experience overall. Extra points for ingeniosity. (+)
Art: 6.5/10 Minis: 7/10 Gameplay: 7.5/10 Overall: 7.25/10

9. Itsmeandersonlol
A nice level with great art, but with mediocre minis. The concept is not so original, and neither is the gameplay. The way you did the water is great tho, and a cool pastel styled shading. The beach and the tree could use some work, but not if that means ruining the art style.
Art: 8/10 Minis: 5.5/10 Gameplay: 6.5/10 Overall: 6.75/10

10. Kingoftheozone
I do hope that you did this level as a joke.....?(?_??) - - - - -
Art: 1/10 Minis: 0/10 Gameplay: 0/10 Overall: 0.25/10

11. DCLevels
Amazing use of the flat/minimalistic level style Extremely relaxing, and really fun.
Minis are great, and the concept is very original, and ingenious. Outstanding job, not much to comment. Big + for the lifes system.
Art: 7/10 Minis: 8.5/10 Gameplay: 9/10 Overall: 8.25/10

12. Numberkirbyfan1O
A not so bad level about a piramid with a weird pinky purple-ish spiritbomb over it. There is not much art to jusge, except for the weird sun/eye thing, and the piramid itself. Basic shaping, no special shading. Minis were good, not ragey, and the gameplay was fun. I found it entertaining somehow.
Art: 3/10 Minis: 4/10 Gameplay: 6/10 Overall: 4.5/10

13. Ipwner
This level has nothing particularly exciting, the art is dull, and minis are very ragey. Looks more like a level that was rushed in 5 min. The only + i can find is the concept, where you have to hold space up to a certain point, but it is still very precision-based and annoying. Please try do put more effort in yout future levels.
Art: 2/10 Minis: 3/10 Gameplay: 2.5/10 Overall: 2.5/10

14. Muffin
Your level was very simple, only using arrows, and low amount of plain colors with no blending nor shading. Not being a show-off, your level was somehow fun and enjoying.
Art: 3/10 Minis: 4/10 Gameplay: 5.5/10 Overall: 4.25/10

15. SmittyW
A fantastic level. The idea of mixing desert with dessert, and making ice cream, which is actually a cold desert dessert is simply ingenious.(+) Art is really great, and eye appealing, and it is user-friendly during gameplay too. What you could have added is some more background art on the dark side of the level, and anti-alias the spoon a bit. Minis were also good, but a bit hard and not in the good way (i found some luck-based challenges which were pretty annoying). Overall this is a good quality level, and a well done job. If only the minis were a bit more enjoyable, i would have given it a close to perfect overall score.
Art:8.5/10 Minis: 7.5/10 Gameplay: 8/10 Overall: 8/10

Last edited by Raon (Mar 6 2014 4:17:37 pm)

Anch · Before February 2015

Lol nice judgeing

Calicara · Before February 2015

If you liked my art how come I only got a 6/10? Can you please give me advice of what I can do better next time?

Noctis · Before February 2015

Yeah, I knew the platform blocks for the palm tree leaves in my level were a bad idea.

Last edited by Noctis (Mar 1 2014 6:17:27 pm)

Master1 · Before February 2015

Wow after seeing Raons reviews, mine are going to suck.

tak4n · Before February 2015

^You think your's suck? I somehow got 6/10 for like most worlds using Mustang's rating system. I had to use calculator as well and I rounded all values to nearest 1.
This is my first time judging and I might alter Mustang's list of things to judge so that I will be able to give out better results for next rounds to come.

Last edited by tak4n (Mar 1 2014 6:59:14 pm)

Chiscorey · Before February 2015

No!, Why I raged that mini? Dx. I promise, I won't change anymore Toxic's work...

iPwner · Before February 2015

@Raon What? Really? This is what I call toiletgloot judging. You were probably sitting on your computer as you were taking a fudging dump (:p), and then as you started *HNGGGG*ing as your thang slipped out, but as you were doing so, someone heard and said "What an A-A-A-A-AAAAAAYHHHNGELLL!! ^_^" and, because you felt encouraged in your incomfort, you decided to instead of letting the dump out into the bowl (:p), you let it out into the review, and looked at the minimaps and said, "Whoopeeydoo, wanna-manna poo," and slapped a disgusting ham-sandwich onto my reviewscore.

Anch · Before February 2015

ipwner wrote:

@Raon What? Really? This is what I call toiletgloot judging. You were probably sitting on your computer as you were taking a fudging dump (:p), and then as you started *HNGGGG*ing as your thang slipped out, but as you were doing so, someone heard and said "What an A-A-A-A-AAAAAAYHHHNGELLL!! ^_^" and, because you felt encouraged in your incomfort, you decided to instead of letting the dump out into the bowl (:p), you let it out into the review, and looked at the minimaps and said, "Whoopeeydoo, wanna-manna poo," and slapped a disgusting ham-sandwich onto my reviewscore.

I totally agree with this.

N1KF · Before February 2015

Raon wrote:

12. Numberkirbyfan1O
Art: 3/10
13. Ipwner
Art: 2/10

I don't even see how you could think my art is better than iPwner's.

Noctis · Before February 2015

Zelda…, how was my minimap art a 5? O_o

ZeldaXD · Before February 2015

Itsmeandersonlol wrote:

Zelda…, how was my minimap art a 5? O_o

Somehow it looked good in my mind.

Noctis · Before February 2015

ZeldaXD wrote:

Itsmeandersonlol wrote:
Zelda…, how was my minimap art a 5? O_o
Somehow it looked good in my mind.

But 5 is an F. 6 is a D. 7 is a C. 8 is a B. 9 is an A and 10 is an A+.

ZeldaXD · Before February 2015

Itsmeandersonlol wrote:

ZeldaXD wrote:
Itsmeandersonlol wrote:
Zelda…, how was my minimap art a 5? O_o
Somehow it looked good in my mind.
But 5 is an F. 6 is a D. 7 is a C. 8 is a B. 9 is an A and 10 is an A+.

Not in spain.

Calicara · Before February 2015

Here is my new level for this week, I call it Neko Roulette. The premise is pretty simple, based off Russian Roulette. You have 3 chances to win, otherwise you are dead. The concept was fortune, and well you need to be fortunate to win this level xD

Link: http://everybodyedits.com/games/PWG2QX-RlAbkI

dragonranger · Before February 2015

Why are all the judges rating tak4ns map...
*facepalm*
His a judge (and isn't even in the final list of teams...)...
The map was just an example...

P.S. You should update the judges thing in the OP

Last edited by Dragonranger (Mar 1 2014 10:01:25 pm)

mrjawapa · Before February 2015

Is fortune as in, what you see in future, or as in i have a great fortune of money?

ZeldaXD · Before February 2015

Master1 wrote:

Wow after seeing Raons reviews, mine are going to suck.

I know that feel bro.

Official Everybody Edits Forums

#176 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#177 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#178 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#179 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#180 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#181 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#182 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#183 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#184 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#185 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#186 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#187 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#188 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#189 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#190 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#191 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#192 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#193 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#194 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#195 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#196 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#197 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#198 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#199 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

#200 Before February 2015

Re: EEC Contest Circuit

Board footer