Official Everybody Edits Forums
Do you think I could just leave this part blank and it'd be okay? We're just going to replace the whole thing with a header image anyway, right?
You are not logged in.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
- Wooted by:
#40 2020-03-01 16:26:48
Re: Mafia 42 - Game Thread - Day 4
peace why are you convinced that kirby is VT?
assuming that he's also not doing night actions (it'd be pretty rude to not post in the thread but still do night actions, so i think this is a fair assumption) kirby could be
- VT
- Mafia Goon (Since we've had two night kills last night, Kirby cannot be the Godfather)
- Vet (Norboy could technically be lying with his counterclaim and Kirby wasn't around to counter-counter-claim --> i seriously doubt this, but it's technically possible i guess)
- Roleblocker (it's technically possible that technically that the mafia and SK targeted the same person N1, but since we've had two conflicting claims, i seriously doubt this also)
kirby cannot be the SK or the Godfather because there was two kills N2 (technically shadow could have tried to frame Norboy, but that is simply idiotic)
practically speaking, kirby could be either the mafia goon or the other VT
i'm more inclined to believe that kirby is the mafia goon, because there are too many other claims for vanilla townies to have them all be true
Remaining Roles:
Mafia Godfather
Mafia Goon
Serial Killer
Veteran
Roleblocker
Vanilla Townie
Vanilla Townie
Remaining Players
let's look at the two claims for roleblocker:
Case A: 2B is the roleblocker
2B blocked Peace N1, and there was only one kill - implying that Peace is one of [Godfather/SK]
This gives us the following roles:
Mafia Godfather - [Peace/Buzz]
Mafia Goon - Kirby
Serial Killer - [Peace/Buzz]
Veteran - Norboy
Roleblocker - 2B
Vanilla Townie - Onjit
Vanilla Townie - Diff (Both 2B and Peace claimed to block Diff, so I think it's a good guess to say he's VT)
Case B: Peace is the roleblocker
Peace blocked Buzz N1, and there was only one kill - implying that Buzz is one of [Godfather/SK]
This would also mean that 2B was lying and is also one of [Godfather/SK]
This gives us the following roles:
Mafia Godfather - [2B/Buzz]
Mafia Goon - Kirby
Serial Killer - [2B/Buzz]
Veteran - Norboy
Roleblocker - Peace
Vanilla Townie - Onjit
Vanilla Townie - Diff (Both 2B and Peace claimed to block Diff, so I think it's a good guess to say he's VT)
Conclusion: If you follow this reasoning, there are two people that are largely confirmed to be scum - Kirby and Buzzerbee. Since Kirby is inactive, our #1 target for today should be Buzzerbee. We can settle between 2B/Peace tomorrow.
!Vote Buzzerbee
:.|:;
Offline
#44 2020-03-01 16:41:40
Re: Mafia 42 - Game Thread - Day 4
Onjit wrote:why is he the VT?
because eithe rme or 2b is the goon becuae eihter oneof us i slying and i seirously doubt VT!2b would fake cliam blocker
why couldn't 2B fakeclaim as the SK or the godfather?
:.|:;
Offline
#45 2020-03-01 16:43:22
Re: Mafia 42 - Game Thread - Day 4
alos i doesnt matter hwo goon or ogdafther is either can kill if one of them is lycnhed
if kirby is the goon, killing the godfather would render the mafia useless, hence, one kill
I think that Buzzerbee is either the Serial killer or the Godfather by process of elimination (re-read my big post, it's not that complicated), so regardless of what his role is, it will mean there is only one kill tonight
:.|:;
Offline
#49 2020-03-01 17:12:49
Re: Mafia 42 - Game Thread - Day 4
the fact that both 2b and peace were willing to lynch buzz leads me to believe buzz is not their teammate
also, i realised that diff being blocked n2 could mean that he is either the goon or the VT, so I think that the setup is some combination of:
Godfather - Buzz
Goon - [Kirby/Diff]
SK - [2B/Peace]
Roleblocker - [2B/Peace]
Veteran - Norboy
VT - Onjit
VT - [Kirby/Diff]
:.|:;
Offline
[ Started around 1732259374.4436 - Generated in 0.109 seconds, 11 queries executed - Memory usage: 1.69 MiB (Peak: 1.91 MiB) ]