Official Everybody Edits Forums

Do you think I could just leave this part blank and it'd be okay? We're just going to replace the whole thing with a header image anyway, right?

You are not logged in.

Donate!

pls donate


#1 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » Yesterday 23:13:18

Don't count out the possibility that Mutant is Mafia. Rat was a safe selection for the Mafia, given her lack of connections with anybody. Mutant is a very good town member, so surface level analysis would lead one to think that the Mafia would try to get rid of him as soon as they can. However, this game is all about deception. If Mutant is town, then the Mafia could benefit by not killing him, as doing so would make him seem more suspicious by virtue of being one of the last few standing. In PurgatorEE, it became doubly useful as Mutant isn't perfect, and makes mistakes, and those mistakes are easy for the Mafia to notice and hide behind, in order for him to take the blame. We still can't ignore the possibility that he really is Mafia.

Keep in mind the above points for other similarly good players in this game.

I've got a post to make about Norwegianboy's flip soon.p0

#3 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-22 08:22:36

TaskManager wrote:

Are you going to argue about something that isn't even part of this game

To be entirely fair to Jawapa and Mutantdevle, you were Mafia last game

#4 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-22 06:37:54

ShadowsEdge wrote:

Norwegian voting to lynch himself doesn't ease anything about the whole situation either. If Norwegian was Mafia, voting for himself would make absolutely no sense.

It makes sense because he's not close to getting lynched, and people in past games have earned townie points for self voting

#6 Re: Forum Games » Refuse Roleplay Request » 2019-08-22 00:22:58

I'm needed elsewhere. You aren't

#7 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-21 22:56:03

No, don't make more people vote for you. You'll already lose by plurality. If you are innocent, then you're going to needlessly make people seem more suspicious by making them hammer for you.

#9 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-21 22:16:05

NorwegianboyEE wrote:

I didn't say that. If you're wondering what i did say, i said that if Slabdrill is voted and flips mafia then the town should lynch me next.

Even more suspicious, because it gives the disguiser a chance to cover you up.

#10 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-21 21:50:32

mrjawapa wrote:

!vote peace

Because his posts are annoying

We already discussed how policy lynching isnt the best idea on day 1 AND have at least two better candidates, and you chose Peace anyway? 🤔

#11 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-21 21:49:13

Just woke up. I'll have to go to class in a few hours, and I'll be staying there for a few more, so I'll share my thoughts.

There are two main lynch targets right now, Slabdrill and Norwegianboy

Slabdrill - Lynching him would remove a largely inactive player from the game. If he flips Mafia, then that's good news for if we enter later stages in this game, as we won't have to worry about reading him. However, whether he flips town or Mafia, it doesn't give us any information on who to trust next. People are still going to suspect Norwegianboy, and if Norboy is indeed Mafia, then the disguiser will surely swap their role card before anyone else.

Norwegianboy - Lynching him would remove an active player in the game, one that if they are town, delivers a lot of useful information to the town. This is bad news if we enter the late game, as we will have one less person to help snuff out who is suspicious. However, we have other people who are capable of being very helpful as well. If we lynch Norwegianboy tonight, however, we will gain certain benefits. Since night 1 is the only night we can get a confirmed flip, we will be certain of Norwegianboy's alignment. If they flip town, then we will know that he was sincere in his words, and we won't have to suspect Slabdrill as much by association with him. If he flips Mafia, however, then we know we won't be able to trust Slabdrill, and we will have a leading lynch target for tomorrow.

I recall someone earlier asking that we should lynch Norboy tonight, and then lynch Slabdrill tomorrow. I don't remember if that was Norboy himself, but if it was, then that would mean he probably isn't the disguised, and he wants the disguiser to cover up Slabdrill, or perhaps it means Slabdrill himself is the disguiser. Either way, we will only gain this information if we lynch Norwegianboy tonight.

Sorry Norboy.
!lynch Norwegianboy

L-2

#12 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-21 11:13:03

This is still night 1, so any lynch we do is going to likely just be a shot in the dark. However  since it's gonna be the only safe flip, we need to make this one count. That's why people are doing a lot more on this night 1 as opposed to other games, rather than just a bandwagon being formed on an inactive person AMD everybody just looking at the people who voted. Brilliant setup imo Kira, it makes it really feel like this first lynch is really important, and we should make it count. That's why I think maybe lynching based off of activity alone isn't the smartest idea.

What do you think of this @Task, Norboy, and Slabdrill?

#13 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-21 09:43:57

@Norwegianboy

Let's say the town decides to lynch Slabdrill and he turns out to be Mafia. What do you think we should do?

What if the town decides to lynch TaskManager, and they flip town? Or any of the other people you mentioned, for that matter

#14 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-21 09:38:01

Thank you for explaining your strategy Norboy. It calms some of the suspicions I have about you. Do know this, though: you and I have played together before and I know how capable you are, so it wouldn't be above you if this were an elaborate lie.

#15 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-21 00:55:46

Refreshing doesn't lead you to the most recent page. Kind of a bad excuse but I understand it at least

#16 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-20 23:08:59

I just wanted to get it out of the way, so that my intentions are 100% clear

#17 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-20 23:07:16

I didnt do that to defend myself, honestly I see it as kind of dumping on myself

#18 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-20 22:28:42

elaboration: I dont mind being a target, itll better let me know who to look into

#19 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-20 22:13:42

TaskManager wrote:

tfw you have to be thankful for people actually playing a game they signed up for

valid

as for how I'm acting right now @Slabdrill
My computer busted in the middle of last game, and I was able to use it less and less, until I just couldn't anymore. I wanted to use that as an excuse to be less active, and to hopefully fly under the radar in the late game, and ride off of what people thought of me earlier on in the game. In this game, I no longer wish to use this as an excuse to be inactive. I'm trying to participate as actively as I can on mobile, and I hope that it shows. For anybody who wishes to suspect me based off of this change, or based off of the fact that I'm pointing it out, then okay. That's valid, but note I dont generally like claiming to be a town member. It isnt that I'm not a townie (even though in the most recent games Im not), but I just dont think it's fair for me to put myself in the town section of my own reads list. Not only would it influence people's thoughts about me possibly either positively or negatively, but it would just be out of character for me. I accept what people say about me in their reads on me, as most often they bring up a valid point. If they don't, or there's a misunderstanding, then I'll try to correct it, and those interactions are what I hope influence people's opinion about me. Statistically speaking, I am possibly a part of the Mafia, but unlikely. I know that I'm a town member, but you don't, and generally I just like to focus on what other people think about each other, and just give what I think about other people. In other words, I dont much like to make it about me. That can be seen as suspicious, or a way of saying "I dont want there to be heat on me", which is valid, but if I die, I die. I just want what I say to help in the end.

#20 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-20 21:58:47

Also, thank you Slabdrill for participating on day 1, and thank you for the read list.

#21 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-20 21:54:38

2B55B5G TNG wrote:

that he's not gonna type whatever comes to mind, I was a little bit suspicious of him, but anyway.

Valid to be wary of this from me, but what I meant was I would try not to let this form of giving my thoughts detract from the structure of my posts. I didnt mean to say that I wouldn't be giving you my full and honest thoughts.

2B55B5G TNG wrote:

I can understand how it's connected to Luka, because both Luka and Mutant pushed for Slabdrill lynch, but why is it connected to me

Only on principle that you took over for Luka. I did note that you dont agree with Luka, though.

#22 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-20 11:56:32

Get well soon JoeyC
(and you too Luka, saying this as I wasnt there for when he was replaced by 2b)

#23 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-20 08:19:39

censors*

what the **** I'm becoming peace

#24 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-20 08:19:09

Yeah, the sendors suck

sorry for not wording that the way I meant to

#25 Re: Forum Games » Mafia 29: The French Revolution Day 2 » 2019-08-20 08:15:51

Sorry I'll elaborate further. The comma in my post should have been made a "for". His willingness to lynch Elei for something you and Luka did a little

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB

[ Started around 1566623018.6823 - Generated in 0.259 seconds, 9 queries executed - Memory usage: 1.53 MiB (Peak: 2.31 MiB) ]